States can’t finance it
Liz Farmer 23, Route Fifty, 4/4/23, “As States Plan for Next Year’s Budget, the Economy Flashes Mixed Signals,” https://www.route-fifty.com/finance/2023/04/states-plan-next-years-budget-economy-flashes-mixed-signals/384784/
But there are signs that the slowdown policymakers keep planning for is getting closer. Recent data from the Urban Institute indicates that state revenue growth, when adjusted for inflation, has started to stall. While sales tax revenue growth has remained strong, income tax revenue is sliding more than expected. Moreover, since the start of this year, the stock market has fallen roughly 5%, tech companies have laid off thousands of workers and the ramifications of Silicon Valley Bank’s collapse are still playing out.
Now, a more mixed picture of state fiscal health is starting to emerge as some states are managing shortfalls even as others report record surpluses.
“Either the economic storm clouds have parted,” opined Oregon’s latest budget forecast, “or we are in the eye of the hurricane.”
Deficits and Surpluses
Preliminary data compiled by the Urban Institute’s Lucy Dadayan show that inflation-adjusted state tax revenues declined during the first seven months of fiscal 2023 (July 2022 through January 2023) compared with the corresponding time period the year before. The median decline was 2.8% while the median drop in personal income tax revenues was 6.9%. Corporate income taxes rose while sales tax revenue inched slightly downward.
“Income tax from [wage] withholding is very weak across all states, which shows me wages are not keeping up with inflation,” Dadayan said. “And the states with more progressive income tax structures and reliance on high income are seeing the biggest declines.”
But only in a few states are the declines translating into budget gaps and California is dealing with the largest gap. Lawmakers there budgeted for a roughly $10 billion decrease in revenue this fiscal year—but the actual drop has been more than twice as much, according to the state’s budget forecast report last fall.