Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchNorthwestern2023Affirmative
Opening Word document…

Repealing BBAs collapses the economy – exceptions still freak out investors

Joe Stone 14, Professor Emeritus of Economics at the University of Oregon, PhD, Economics, Michigan State University, M.A., Economics, Michigan State University, July 20 (“Do balanced-budget rules increase growth?” https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/57605/13/MPRA_paper_57605.pdf)

VI. DISCUSSION Given the regression estimates in Table (2), we are now in a position to discuss whether or not BBRs change the effect of debt on growth, and if so, how. The significantly positive coefficient for the ACIR-debt interaction suggests that the answer to the first question is ‘yes’: more stringent BBRs make debt more productive, consistent with the WW view that these rules increase the productiveness of debt by restricting borrowing to productive public infrastructure. This effect could work either directly through the greater productivity of investments in public infrastructure or more indirectly by assuring lenders that future borrowing will be limited to public infrastructure, resulting in lower costs of borrowing. Both channels are consistent with the evidence in Alt and Lowry (1997) and others that borrowing costs are lower for states with more stringent budget rules. How large is the effect of BBRs on the productivity of debt in terms of growth? With no BBR in place (i.e., with an ACIR index of zero) and evaluated at sample means, the coefficients in Table (2) indicate that a one standard-deviation increase in the stock of debt (an increase of 5.6 percent of personal income) decreases the steady-state (five-year) growth rate by 17.4 percent of real income—just over 3 percent per year. However, with a strict BBR in place (i.e., with an ACIR index of 10), the coefficients predict instead an increase in the steady-state (fiveyear) growth rate of about 15 percent for a one-standard-deviation increase in debt. VII. POLICY CONSIDERATIONS Evidence elsewhere indicates that balanced-budget rules [BBRs] lower borrowing costs and restrain levels of state and local debt. Our evidence also indicates that high levels of debt can slow growth, but our unique contribution is to provide an arguably well-identified test of the hypothesis that state-level balanced-budget restrictions [BBRs] in the U. S. increase growth by restricting borrowing to productive public infrastructure. Evidence that state balanced-budget restrictions increase growth via this channel provides the first formal test of the WW hypothesis and adds a new perspective to the effects of balanced-budget rules by suggesting that the benefits of tax smoothing and fiscal flexibility (permitted in the absence of a balanced-budget restriction) may come at the expense of lower growth. We close however, with caveats; we provide evidence relevant to the WW hypothesis, not a comprehensive analysis of the merits of balanced-budget and other fiscal restrictions. In particular, the context for fiscal policy differs in obvious and important ways for countries and sub-national states. Auerbach (2007) for example, analyzes federal fiscal policy ‘rules’ and issues for recent decades.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.