Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchNorthwestern2023Affirmative
Opening Word document…

Progressive taxes are effective---assumes their offense.

Nezih Guner et al 23, researcher at the Autonomous University of Barcelona, associated to CEPR and IZA. 6-24-2023, "'With a proportional income tax, the best universal basic income can be more generous'," Le Monde, https://www.lemonde.fr/en/opinion/article/2022/06/29/with-a-proportional-income-tax-the-best-universal-basic-income-can-be-more-generous_5988397_23.html

The current transfers in the US take various forms: wage subsidies, per-child transfers, food vouchers, childcare subsidies, housing assistance, or direct cash transfers, all targeted at households with no or low earnings. For some demographic groups, such as single mothers, transfers represent a significant source of income. Transfers and other government expenditures are financed by different forms of taxation, but mainly by a progressive income tax.

Proportional income tax

Suppose we replace all these programs with a UBI. We find that the best possible UBI is about 2600$ (2500 euros), so a married couple with two children will get about 10,000 euros annually. The size of total transfers will be about 4.7% of GDP, and higher distortionary taxes are necessary to pay for the extra spending. If individuals were asked whether they would rather live in an economy with a universal basic income, 60% would say yes.

But many individuals, especially those at the bottom of the income distribution, are pretty unhappy with this change. The transfers are targeted at the low-income individuals in the current system, so they are getting more than 2,500 euros. But, a more generous universal basic income is not feasible since it will imply even higher taxes. Higher taxes generate negative incentives for labor supply and savings, forcing the government to collect taxes from a smaller tax base.

Is it possible to make things better? We find that a UBI and a tax reform that moves from the current progressive taxes to a proportional income tax can do better. A proportional tax provides stronger incentives for work and savings than a progressive income tax.

As a result, it is possible to collect more taxes and expand the size of the transfers. With a proportional income tax, the best UBI can be more generous. The US government can now give each 3,900$ (3,700 euros) annually, and the size of transfers increases to 7.3% of GDP, more than three times the current level.

Welfare state reform

Two messages emerge from our analysis: First, a UBI program is expensive. The existing targeted transfers to low-income individuals can be significant, and extending them to all individuals requires substantial tax increases.

Second, rethinking the welfare state requires a reform that not only introduces a UBI but also considers the most efficient way to raise revenue, which in our study turns out to be a move to a proportional income tax. As tax distortions are reduced with a proportional tax, the size of the aggregate economy grows, making higher degrees of redistribution feasible.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.