Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchNorthwestern2023Affirmative
Opening Word document…

Only the counterplan alone solves the case. Tax and transfer financing eradicates the benefits of UBI

Mohammad Rasoolinejad 21, Postdoctoral Research Fellow, Northwestern University Kellogg School of Management, 2021, “Universal Basic Income: The Last Bullet in the Darkness,” https://arxiv.org/pdf/1910.05658.pdf

UBI can be funded through money printing, deficit spending or by revenue from taxes. In the first case, the base money supply will increase. The risk with this case is raising inflation. As long as inflation is under control, money printing can help in many other issues (such as alleviating national debt or increasing comparative advantage of country in the trade) in a manner that is fair to everyone. The following sections will elaborate more on the benefits that money printing can provide.

The government will issue the notes to fund the UBI program in deficit spending. This case resembles transferring money from the wealthy (local or foreign) to the middle class and poor. However, the lower and middle class become endebted to the wealthy and their debt must be paid at a later time. Deficit spending may also cause inflation, as lower-income households tend to spend a higher percentage of household income. This method is not preferable, as raising money through debt issuing is not sustainable in the long run.

Funding UBI with tax income is also transferring money from the wealthy to the middle class and poor, except this time the money will not be paid back. UBI can be funded through land/location value tax (LVT), value-added tax (VAT) or income tax. Some have also suggested the use of Robot-tax, which penalizes industries for the use of automation instead of human labor [10]. To punish industries for technological advancements, however, is irrational. This will reduce the comparative advantage of local industries. The disadvantage with income tax is that raising taxes on the wealthy usually hinders economic growth. Between the suggested taxation methods, the VAT seems the best option, as the program is funded by the individuals who spend the most, and it encourages people to save. Here and through the rest of the paper, we assume UBI is funded by money printing. The author believes other methods will decrease or eradicate the purpose of implementing UBI in the first place.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.