Climate refugees won’t cause war
Nils Petter Gleditsch 11, Research professor at the Centre for the Study of Civil War, Peace Research Institute Oslo, and Professor of political science, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, January 28, 2011, “Regional Conflict and Climate Change,” online: http://yosemite.epa.gov/ee/epa/eerm.nsf/vwAN/EE-0566-122.pdf/$file/EE-0566-122.pdf
IPCC (2007, WG II: 323) forecasts a global mean sea-level rise of between 0.28 and 0.43 meters within this century, depending on the scenario chosen.7 Projections for the size of coastal populations (residing below 100 m elevation and less than 100 km from the coast) show that they may rise from 1.2 billion (1990 estimate) to between 1.8 and 5.2 billion (Nicholls & Small, 2002). Sea level rise will threaten the livelihood of the populations on small island states in the Indian Ocean, the Caribbean, and the Pacific. However, a much larger number of people in low-lying areas, rural and urban, and particularly in South Asia and West Africa, may become more exposed to soil erosion, seasonal flooding, and extreme weather. Depending on the degree of protection that can be offered, this may lead to ‘climate migration’, and conflict with the host population is a possible consequence (Nicholls & Tol, 2006). However, this is going to be a slow process and urbanization and industrialization may well absorb a large fraction of the people who move.
In a global study covering the period 1951–2001, Salehyan & Gleditsch (2006) found that an influx of refugees increased the probability of civil war. However, since a large proportion of these people have fled from conflict, they are likely to bring with them the attitudes, the weapons, and the organization that fuel a continuation of the conflict in the host location. It is not obvious that economic migrants, including environmental migrants, will generate armed conflict in the same way (Gleditsch, Nordås & Salehyan, 2007). However, this has not been studied systematically, due to conceptual problems (what is the definition of an environmental migrant?) and lack of systematic data. Reuveny (2007) examined 38 cases of environmental migration since the 1930s and found that in half of them there was some kind of armed conflict, most frequently when the migration cross international boundaries. While suggestive, his study is unlikely to include all cases of environmental migration during this period and the conflicts are of different types. Moreover, he did not have any control variables.