Turn: Vagueness of a ‘just transition’ collapses local implementation of green jobs and infrastructure development
Banerjee and Schuitema, University College Dublin researchers, ’22
(Aparajita Banerjee, Post-Doctoral Research Fellow at College of Business at University College Dublin; Geertje Schuitema, Associate Professor in Consumer Behaviour and Technology Adoption at UCD's College of Business, “How just are just transition plans? Perceptions of decarbonisation and low-carbon energy transitions among peat workers in Ireland,” Energy Research & Social Science, Volume 88, June 2022, 102616, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.erss.2022.102616)
A just transition is often described as an ideology [8], [25], that is, a system of ideas and ideals that aims to reduce the negative impact of energy transition on vulnerable groups. This idea of a just transition as an ideology has gained much traction in recent years, especially in the context of decarbonisation and the energy transition. On an ideological level, stakeholders have reached consensus that vulnerable groups should be protected and supported. This, however, is often challenging in practice, as the interpretation of what is just and how a just transition is achieved is often approached from very different perspectives. In the case study presented in this paper, we found that, in principle, all key stakeholders, including peat workers and community members, agreed that a just transition programme for the Irish Midlands was a critical policy tool that could support vulnerable groups. We also found, however, an apparent discrepancy between the “theory” and “practice” of the just transition. That is, those who were meant to be supported by the just transition felt that the just transition programme itself fell short on its basic tenet (i.e being “just”).
The gap between the “theory” and “practice” of the just transition has resulted in much frustration, anxiety, feelings of betrayal and anger among peat workers. These emotions were exacerbated by the promise of a just transition, which in the eyes of the workers was not upheld. Overall, the workers expressed strong scepticism towards the effectiveness of the just transition programme and distrusted the political motivations behind the implementation of a just transition. Such scepticism and distrust regarding just transition programmes can undermine local support for regional development and green jobs, most relevantly in the renewable energy sector [30], [62], [63], [64], [65], [66], [67], [68]. A transition to renewable energy is often planned for these regions but it can stall owing to local resistance, which can hinder, delay or block it [68]. Therefore, a failed just transition process in the eyes of the public can have detrimental effects on energy transition.
In response to the frustrations that arose in the Irish Midlands among peat workers and their communities, the Irish government recognised the need to make changes. Delivering a just transition in the Irish Midlands is among the core goals of the Climate Action Plan 2021 [69]. A rural development plan was also proposed in the same framework [69], which can be described as a recovery plan to boost development that aims to revitalise the Irish countryside [70]. This builds on principles of restorative justice. Regional plans are also being established to address the skills and training needs of stakeholders in the Irish Midlands [71]. A recent report, however, suggests that Ireland has yet to prepare a territorial just transition plan for accessing the European Union Just Transition Fund [72]. In sum, the Irish government's goal to promote social justice by aligning the just transition process with local demands delivered mixed results when the government was faced with the consequences of its hasty decision to suspend the operation of the peat industry in the Irish Midlands, which led to a wave of frustrations and criticism from local stakeholders.
The management of the Irish Midlands' just transition process and its aftermath provides key lessons for other regions that will need to phase out fossil fuel in the future. This, however, comes too late for the workers and communities in the Irish Midlands. The most important lesson to be drawn is that to translate distributive, procedural and restorative justice principles into concrete objectives and action points a clear just transition process needs to be in place. This article has argued that the key element missing from the Irish Midlands case was such a process to safeguard the transformation of an ideology of just transition into the reality of a just transition programme. We argue that such a process should be led by an independent party, which must be fully aware of the theoretical basis for a just transition, and should also be based on justice principles. In order to put principles into practice, individual and objective conversations need to be conducted with all relevant stakeholders. Understanding their interpretation of a just transition is pivotal for the success of this process. Justice principles can be used to structure these conversations, as they act as a bridge between the ideological objectives of justice and the practical interventions needed to achieve them [25]. An iterative process of analyses, discussions and consensus-finding among stakeholders on these interpretations is needed in order to build trust and, most importantly, to align expectations from a just transition programme. These discussions should include short-term and long-term planning. Short- to mid-term planning typically focuses on distributive and procedural justice components and includes the broader social and economic impact of transitions on workers, communities and regions. Conversely, long-term planning needs to focus on restorative justice and the allocation of regional investments for the creation of parallel industries, which would ensure that workers can continue to thrive. Importantly, the planning process should safeguard the equal treatment of all stakeholders and their needs to avoid power imbalances. It is important that they can all feel able to speak freely and openly about them and that their views will be taken seriously. Addressing these issues requires time to reflect and run consultation groups and negotiations with all stakeholders. Any reactions that are likely to take place should be mitigated with relevant measures that can be built in the process.
In conclusion, the growing consensus is that carbon-intensive industries need to be phased out. As a consequence of this process, socioeconomic disruption and changes in the local industrial landscape can be expected in many parts of the world. The just transition in the Irish Midlands illustrates how the sudden decision to shut down an industry can undermine the just transition process. It has become plain that the declaration that a transition is just is not tantamount to fact. By neglecting to seek consensus on how distributive, procedural and restorative justice can be achieved in practice, strong negative emotions and distrust among those who are affected are likely to emerge. In turn, this may result in a sub-optimal just transition process, which may stall energy transition. A just transition influences public support for renewable energy projects and climate change policies and, if absent, tends to undermine trust in the relevant industries and government as a whole. Our case study demonstrates the importance of using theoretically constructed justice principles to create just transition programmes in practice, which engage all stakeholders. Given that many countries are in the process of phasing out fossil fuels, this case study provides valuable lessons on the pitfalls to avoid on the way to designing a just transition.