Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

We simply would not be able to find enough jobs

Gulker, AIER researcher ‘18

[Max Gulker, Senior Research Fellow, American Insitute for Economic Research,“The Dangerous Fantasy of a ‘Jobs Guarantee’,” WALL STREET JOURNAL, 11—14—18, , accessed 6-8-23]

Beyond its cost, the job guarantee would turn the fundamental logic of work on its head. Generally, people work for employers, whether private organizations or government agencies, because employees add enough value to sustain their wages and still benefit the employer. Under a job guarantee, creating value is an afterthought. The program's potential is limited further by additional rules the authors propose, such as barring competition with existing private or public jobs and requiring that the positions be low-skilled.

Finding enough work for more than 10 million people would be a herculean task. The authors have a kind imagination: Among their ideas are caring for children and the elderly, clearing vacant lots and building community theaters. But they make no attempt to show how or even if the work could be assigned. The proposal suggests that these decisions should be made at the local level, which begs the question.

Suppose you are mayor of a city of 300,000 people. The federal government has asked you to assign 9,000 people to low-skilled jobs that don't overlap with work your government and businesses already do. That number would likely double in a recession. It would take every department in city hall to keep the enrollees matched with productive work. The predicament recalls the 1985 comedy "Brewster's Millions," in which Richard Pryor's character must spend millions of dollars as quickly as possible without regard for the value of what he buys. People's labor, which usually has considerable value, would become a burden on those expected to employ them.

The program's administration, virtually ignored by the authors, would present numerous opportunities for corruption, such as businesses bribing officials for free labor. Monitoring such a colossal program would be difficult and expensive. Companies also would seek to influence the program's public works. A big-box retail chain, for instance, might want a community to prioritize the clearing of a vacant lot next to one of its stores.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.