Decentralization will not solve the job-matching problem
Gulker, AIER researcher ‘18
[Max Gulker, Senior Research Fellow, American Insitute for Economic Research, “Proposed Federal Jobs Guarantee Is Too Big to Exist,” American Institute for Economic Research, 5—4—18, , accessed 6-8-23]
My concerns that follow are less about the standard partisan debate on big government programs, and more about the profound implications of dropping an organization of this size on the U.S. labor market. No matter one’s political leanings, these concerns should not be dismissed.
The first major concern is how the federal jobs guarantee would be implemented run. Imagine you’re the first program director. You and your crack team of economists, human-resources professionals, and labor attorneys will need to think of something for 12 to 17 million Americans, mostly with lower skills, to do on a full-time basis. Then you’ll need to do your best to match each worker with a job that fits his or her skills. We usually have individual choice and market prices to sort this out. No attempt in history to solve an economic problem of this magnitude in any other way has come close to succeeding.
The Levy Institute has the right instinct when it says it prefers a “highly decentralized program,” where jobs are created and given out at a community level. But there’s a limit to how decentralized something can be when it’s being funded by a multi-hundred-billion-dollar federal program that is at the whim of national politicians and ultimately the electorate.