The workers attracted to the program would not have the skills to complete the projects they describe
Gulker, AIER researcher ‘19
[Max Gulker, Senior Research Fellow, American Insitute for Economic Research, “The Job Guarantee Strikes Back,” American Institute for Economic Research, 3—8—19, , accessed 6-8-23]
Miller implies that I am wrong to worry about the job guarantee leading to “economic disaster.” By peeling away millions from the private sector into a system that is necessarily inferior in assigning jobs, disaster could indeed ensue. Miller accurately summarizes concerns expressed by economist Dean Baker and me that the program would attract millions more than the authors intend. But before he has a chance to explain why we’re wrong or why this wouldn’t be a bad thing, he suddenly pivots.
“The goal of a job guarantee could be accomplished by public-sector spending large enough to bring about genuine full employment,” writes Miller, shifting his focus for the remainder of the article to a more traditional government stimulus-and-employment program.
Many of the potential government jobs Miller highlights, such as infrastructure, healthcare, and clean-energy technology, are expressly excluded from the Levy job-guarantee proposal. The Levy economists’ “human buffer stock” must be kept busy with tasks that do not require special skills and do not directly compete with specific private sector industries.
Miller’s choice of government jobs underscores the problematic trade-offs inherent in any large government employment program cleverly termed the “impossible quadrilateral” by Hugh Sturgess. The jobs Miller proposes promise more value to society than the chores favored by the Levy Institute, but necessarily raise issues of skill requirements and nationalizing entire industries.
Unskilled workers might be able to help out with large infrastructure or clean-energy projects, but these require skilled contractors, workers, and even scientists. How will Miller’s plan attract these workers from the private sector? How much will the government pay? And as resources are diverted from the private sector, those issues of the inferior allocation of resources rear their head again.