EITC comparatively better for economy and work incentives than FJG – prefer the CP
Pethokoukis, Senior Fellow AEI, 2018
[James “Thinking About (much) Better Pro-work Ideas Than a Cartoonish Federal Jobs Guarantee” AEI May 01, 2018https://www.aei.org/economics/thinking-about-much-better-pro-work-ideas-than-a-cartoonish-federal-jobs-guarantee/ accessed 6.15.23 prejcp-TM]
The idea of a federal jobs guarantee, perhaps last seen in the enjoyable 1993 film “Dave,” is the hot-take economic policy on the left at the moment. (Sorry, universal basic income, your 15 minutes appear to be up.) Now there are many, many problems with a federal jobs guarantee. In a recent blog post, economist Timothy Taylor highlights lots of them, at least regarding the undercooked Bernie Sanders version. There’s a government managerial problem, a jobs-skills mismatch problem, a geographical mismatch problem, a worker displacement problem, a worker discipline and incentive problem, a “what happens to existing anti-poverty programs” problem, and, of course, a budgetary problem. Lots of problems. You really can’t hand-wave these away. Taylor also includes some commentary by Mother Jones’ Kevin Drum, which really shows why the jobs guarantee fails the sniff test. Drum: Since this is just a proposal, let’s also suppose that Bernie is proposing universal health care and a minimum wage of $15, which we know he supports. In that case, everyone with a job would be just as well off keeping it. However, there would still be millions who don’t have a job and want one, and more millions who might not like their jobs and would prefer a government job that’s a little cushier. How many is that? Maybe 5 million? 10 million? And probably more like 15-20 million during a recession. That’s still pretty damn close to insane. It’s about 3-10 percent of the labor force effectively nationalized forever by the federal government, which makes it roughly comparable to the emergency labor force employed for a few years by the WPA during the depths of the Depression. This is why even our lefty comrades in social democratic Europe don’t guarantee jobs for everyone. It would cost a fortune; it would massively disrupt the private labor market; it would almost certainly tank productivity; and it’s unlikely in the extreme that the millions of workers in this program could ever be made fully competent at their jobs. That’s what we in the commentary business call a reality check. But of course government should not be indifferent to encouraging work. This from my AEI colleague Michael Strain in a piece for Bloomberg: The right place to start is with policies to help individuals become more successful workers. One example is the federal earned-income tax credit, which uses taxpayer dollars to subsidize the earnings of low-income, working households. By increasing the financial rewards of working, previous EITC expansions have pulled people into the workforce. Or take work-based learning programs, like apprenticeships, which can be successful by combining skill-building with formal instruction in order to increase workers’ productivity and wages.