EITC expansion to universal tax credit for individuals to maximum of 10k provides support and reduces poverty – and if automation claims of the aff are correct, could convert to UBI
Capps, 2019
[Kriston, “Is This the Universal Basic Income That Americans Will Buy?” Bloomberg News May 30 2019 prejcp-tm]
As it’s currently construed, the Earned Income Tax Credit supports working low-income households with children. It’s a substantial enough subsidy that these households plan their annual spending around it. Anyone who has ever eagerly anticipated a tax refund understands this, although for some working families the credit can amount to as much as 40 percent of annual household income. Yet the Earned Income Tax Credit is only progressive-ish at best, since it provides little to no help for working households without children or for middle-class families. Burman’s paper calls for replacing the Earned Income Tax Credit with a Universal Earned Income Tax Credit, which would “provide meaningful assistance for low- and middle-income workers whether or not they have children living with them.” This universal tax credit “would not directly penalize two-earner couples,” he writes. The fixes are straightforward, albeit ambitious: The universal tax credit would be based on individual income, not household income, so dual-income households would benefit. Family makeup would no longer be a factor, so childless workers would earn more from the credit, too. The universal credit would apply to 100 percent of earnings up to a maximum $10,000, extending its reach into the lower middle class. Burman also tacks on changes to the the Child Tax Credit, making it fully refundable, which would be a huge boost for very low-income parents. Further, Burman proposes a way to pay for the Universal Earned Income Tax Credit: a new value-added tax of 11 percent. If nobody works at all, thanks to the robots, then the Universal Earned Income Tax Credit could easily be converted to a traditional UBI program. That pay-for element distinguishes the Tax Policy Center concept from Senator Cory Booker’s Rise Credit, Senator Kamala Harris’s LIFT the Middle Class Act, Senator Sherrod Brown’s Working Families Tax Relief Act, or the Economic Security Project’s Cost of Living Refund—all of which are otherwise fairly same-same. Any eventual effort to improve or expand the tax refund as part of the social safety net is bound to draw from some or all these drafts. The idea is to accomplish through the tax code what might be impossible through legislation, given the current partisan gridlock.