States should implement EITC – refundability of full amount key to address poverty
Waxman and Hinh, CBPP, 2023
[SAMANTHA WAXMAN AND IRIS HINH “States Can Enact or Expand Child Tax Credits and Earned Income Tax Credits to Build Equitable, Inclusive Communities and Economies” CBPP MARCH 3, 2023 GDI-TM]
*figure omitted
Child tax credits and EITCs can boost incomes for families paid low wages, for adults not raising children who work low-paid jobs, and for caregivers facing barriers to employment. They can also help address imbalances in the tax system that ask the most of people who earn the least. Eleven states have adopted child tax credits, and 31 states plus D.C. and Puerto Rico have adopted state EITCs. (See Figure 3.) Refundability is a key feature of these credits and the source of much of their ability to boost income, reduce poverty, and help families in the long run. It means that if the credit exceeds a filer’s tax liability, some or all of the credit is paid out as a refund. In the case of refundable state EITCs, filers can receive the full credit amount they are eligible for based on their earnings, no matter how much they owe at tax time. Refundable state child tax credits provide families with the maximum amount of the credit regardless of earnings (with no phase-in).[9] Without these provisions, the credits leave out families who earn the least. Most state child tax credits provide a flat amount per child and phase out at a specified income; some are tied to federal eligibility rules and amounts. California and Vermont provide the largest credits: California’s Young Child Tax Credit provides up to $1,083 to families with a child under 6 in the home, and Vermont provides up to $1,000 for each child under 6. Most state EITCs are modeled directly on the federal credit: they use federal EITC eligibility rules and match a specified percentage of the federal credit. EITCs that provide the full credit filers are eligible for, regardless of tax owed, range from 3 percent of the federal credit in Montana to 100 percent in D.C., the latter once it’s fully phased in in tax year 2026.[10] (See Figure 4 below for characteristics of federal EITC recipients by state, and Appendix Table 1 for more details on each state’s credits.) To help more families make ends meet during the pandemic recovery and beyond, states without a child tax credit or EITC should adopt them and those with these tax credits should continue to expand them.