COVID EITC expired – Congress and the states should expand EITC and child tax credits
Waxman and Hinh, CBPP, 2023
[SAMANTHA WAXMAN AND IRIS HINH “States Can Enact or Expand Child Tax Credits and Earned Income Tax Credits to Build Equitable, Inclusive Communities and Economies” CBPP MARCH 3, 2023 GDI-TM]
*figure omitted
*ITINs – individual taxpayer identification number
States Can Build Stronger Futures by Enacting and Strengthening Child Tax Credits and EITCs Several design aspects of the federal Child Tax Credit and EITC constrain its potential to boost income and help struggling families make ends meet. These aspects in turn limit state credits that are based on these federal credits in whole or in part. A family who earns less than $2,500 receives no federal Child Tax Credit, and a single parent with two children who earns between $2,500 and roughly $30,000 receives only a partial credit. The child credit is only partially refundable, which means that the lowest-income families may not receive the credit’s full value. For people without children in the home, the federal EITC has age restrictions, is small, and phases out at too low of an income level. Both federal credits restrict eligibility for people or children who have ITINs, with the Child Tax Credit excluding children who have ITINs and the EITC excluding individuals and families if any member has an ITIN. The Rescue Plan temporarily addressed some of these challenges by making the maximum value of the Child Tax Credit available to children in families with low or no earnings, raising the maximum credit and boosting it for children under age 6, and extending the credit to 17-year-olds. It also temporarily expanded the age range of workers eligible for the EITC without children to include younger adults aged 19-24 (excluding students under 24 who are attending school at least part time), as well as people aged 65 and over, and raised the income limit for such workers to qualify. Both expansions were for 2021 only. Congress should take action to expand the federal Child Tax Credit, and the EITC for adults not raising children, and states should continue to improve state credits for workers without children in the home in the meantime. States can lessen these constraints in their own versions of the credits and take steps to improve the equity of their tax systems by: Enacting new, refundable credits. Eleven states have enacted a state child tax credit, and 31 states plus D.C. and Puerto Rico have created a state EITC. Given both credits’ benefits for families, communities, and states, and the need to continue supporting families through this phase of the pandemic recovery, now is an ideal time to act for states that haven’t yet enacted either credit. (See Appendix Table 3 and 4 for estimating the cost of creating a new credit.) Making credits refundable (if they are not already). Eight states offer refundable child tax credits, and 26 states, D.C., and Puerto Rico follow the federal practice of offering an EITC that is refundable to families with low earnings in a given year. Without this feature, state child tax credits and EITCs fail to offset the other substantial state and local taxes that families pay, such as sales and property taxes. Ending exclusions for individuals using ITINs. States should make their credits more inclusive for people regardless of their immigration status, as six states have already done for their child tax credits and nine have done for their EITCs. That would help expand economic opportunity for all their residents and support essential workers earning low pay who are immigrants. Federal policymakers excluded millions of immigrants from many of the emergency pandemic supports they enacted in 2020 and 2021. Looking at the EITC specifically, many of those same people are ineligible because they lack Social Security numbers and file taxes with an ITIN. If more states with EITCs enacted this change, it would help at least 1.1 million households. (See Table 1.) In addition, the following principles should guide states as they design their own child tax credits: Provide a flat amount per child with a phase-out at higher incomes. This structure is simple to calculate and understandable for families. The full credit should be available to families whether or not they have earned income, with a phase-out beginning at higher levels of income, when families are on more stable footing. The Rescue Plan’s temporary expansion began to phase out the credit at incomes ranging from $75,000 to $150,000 depending on filing status. Adjust the credit for inflation so that it maintains its value over time. Especially given the rapid price increases in the past year-plus, this provision ensures that the credit would be available to help families with any increases in the cost of food, fuel, and other necessities. (The federal EITC upon which most state EITCs are based is already adjusted for inflation each year, although as noted the 2017 tax law changed the inflation measure to one that erodes the credit’s value over time.[30]) Provide a credit for all children aged 0 to 17, with an extra boost for children aged 5 and under. There are compelling reasons both to offer a credit that is available to all children aged 0 to 17 and to boost the credit for families with young children. The Rescue Plan took this approach in 2021, offering a credit worth $3,600 for children 5 and under and $3,000 for all other children through age 17. Families with very young children tend to have lower incomes and experience higher poverty rates than households without children, due to the difficulty of balancing caregiving needs and the need to earn income.[31] In addition, research has found links between poor nutrition and severe stress in early childhood and worse health outcomes later in life. An increased child tax credit for families with young children can boost family incomes when families most need the support, and support children’s health and development in their earliest years. And providing a child tax credit for all children up to age 18 recognizes that expenses increase as children age, with the highest expenses for families falling in teenage years.[32]Furthermore, additional income such as what the child tax credit and EITC provide has been linked to better educational outcomes while children are in school and may improve higher education access and outcomes.[33]