FJG inefficient – lack of training, quality of work and cost make it comparatively worse then EITC
Riedl, senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute, 2018
[Brian “Fantasyland Economics” City Journal, May 1 2018 prejcp-tm]
Imagine that Washington has hired 10 million unemployed and underemployed workers, raided industries like retail and fast food, and attracted millions of people who have been out of the labor force for years. What does the government do with 20 to 35 million lower-skilled workers? As Megan McArdle notes, most infrastructure projects require extensive training in operating heavy machinery. Teaching and day care require degrees and certifications. Basic landscaping, janitorial services, and beautifying public property require little training, but the economy does not need 20 million people performing them. The senators’ proposal is inspired by a vision of workers as widgets that can be easily slotted into any function, wherever they’re needed. In practice, though, the kinds of projects that get done will be dictated not by public need but by the characteristics of workers with few skills and little training. Having workers cycle in and out of the system based on the business cycle, seasonal job trends, and the ability to find private sector work would saddle these public projects with constant turnover, retraining, and upheaval. There is a moral hazard to the proposal, as well. If everyone is guaranteed a $15 per hour government job with full benefits, can they never be fired? If so, then there will be little incentive to work hard. A guaranteed government jobs program would also attract those who cannot keep a private-sector job due to behavioral issues such as harassment, threats, and abuse. Perhaps these workers would simply be transferred from project to project, or segregated from others—essentially collecting a $30,000 salary, plus benefits, without adding any real value. The families paying enormous taxes to support such individuals may not be amused. Expecting the government that brought us the DMV, Post Office, and an unusable Obamacare website to operate competently a jobs program for more than 20 million workers is fantasyland economics. The scale of the program would require the largest federal bureaucratic structure in American history, outside of World War II. Massive incompetence, corruption, and mismanagement would be inevitable. There is no easy path to creating plentiful, well-paying jobs. Rather than launching another break-the-bank government program, lawmakers should instead focus on encouraging economic growth, supporting education and job training, and expanding policies such as the EITC.