EITC solves better than UBI—work incentive and cost link differential
Progressive Policy Institute ‘19
[staff, “UBI Is the Wrong Way to Fight Poverty,” Progressive Policy Institute, 10—3—19, , accessed 6-14-23]
If UBI doesn’t make economic sense, what does? Expanding the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) is a better way to supplement the market income of Americans in need. The EITC is a refundable tax credit that phases in at a percentage of a taxpayer’s earned income until the credit reaches a maximum benefit. If the taxpayer’s income rises above a certain threshold, the EITC begins to phase out. This benefit structure incentivizes taxpayers whose incomes are in the phase-in region to work more because each additional dollar they earn also raises the value of their tax credit. The opposite is true for people whose incomes are higher than the phase-out threshold, as earning more income reduces the value of the credit, which may dampen the incentive to work. But people who do not have jobs only face an incentive to begin working, and empirical evidence shows that the EITC’s incentives to work strongly outweigh the disincentives. As such, expanding the EITC would put money in the hands of working people without the risk of discouraging too many people from participating in the labor force.
An EITC expansion would be better targeted than a UBI towards those who need support the most, so it can provide significant benefits to those who truly need them for a fraction of the cost. The EITC’s phase-out structure directs almost all of the credit to households in the bottom 60 percent of the income distribution, and the largest benefits to those in the bottom 40 percent. In 2017, the EITC lifted 5.7 million people above the poverty line (including 3 million children) without paying out large benefits for wealthy people that a UBI would.