Answer to states can’t solve – no income tax not an obstacle
Waxman and Hinh, CBPP, 2023
[SAMANTHA WAXMAN AND IRIS HINH “States Can Enact or Expand Child Tax Credits and Earned Income Tax Credits to Build Equitable, Inclusive Communities and Economies” CBPP MARCH 3, 2023 GDI-TM]
*figure omitted
States Without an Income Tax Can Enact a State Child Tax Credit and EITC
In the nine states without an income tax, state revenue departments typically do not collect the information about family income and structure needed to determine credit eligibility. Nevertheless, it is feasible for these states to enact and implement these credits, and the example of Washington State’s Working Families Tax Rebate illustrates how implementing an EITC could work.
Washington State finally funded its Working Families Tax Credit in 2021, which policymakers created in 2008 but hadn’t implemented due to the Great Recession and resulting budget shortfalls. The newly implemented credit provides larger rebates to families and is inclusive of people who file taxes with an ITIN. Starting in 2023, more than 400,000 households with low and moderate incomes across the state will receive an annual financial boost of up to $300 for a single person and $1,200 for a family of four or more through the credit (there is no phase-in for the credit).
Eligible families will apply to the Washington Department of Revenue to receive the credit. The state will verify eligibility by retroactively matching IRS data to the application. The bill directs the revenue department to work with the IRS to pay the rebate automatically as soon as is feasible.a The IRS provides these data to state revenue departments under a data-sharing arrangement and could work with Washington State to share data more quickly to facilitate an automatic program.
Any of the eight other states without a broad-based income tax (Alaska, Florida, Nevada, New Hampshire, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, and Wyoming) could follow Washington’s model. State child tax credits and EITCs could be particularly helpful in these states because their tax systems rely heavily on excise taxes, property taxes, and in most cases, sales taxes. Because of this reliance, low- and moderate-income families in these states tend to pay a significantly higher share of their income in state taxes than wealthier families.