Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

No work incentives – studies incorrectly value impact of welfare reform and good economy on previous EITC expansions

VerBruggen, Institute for Family Studies research fellow, 2019

[Robert, “The Ineffective Earned Income Tax Credit”, Institute for Family Studies SEPTEMBER 25, 2019 prejcp-TM]

*figure omitted

The Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) is a major part of America's work-focused safety net. At the end of each tax year, parents who work but have low incomes can receive up to $6,557 (as of 2019). Conservatives like it because it rewards work; liberals like it because it helps poor families. Some on both sides have suggested expanding it, especially for childless workers, who receive far smaller credits than those with children (just $529 this year). An impressive new paper from Princeton’s Henrik Kleven, however, argues that the pro-work impact of the EITC has been hugely overstated. Indeed, it implies that the credit has done essentially nothing to increase work. This doesn't mean we should repeal it. But it does mean we should give serious thought to reworking how it operates. Researchers have long thought that the expansion of the EITC in 1993 played an important role in the dramatic increase in single mothers' labor-force participation in the years that followed. However, it's always been difficult to separate the impact of the EITC from that of welfare reform and the overall strong economy. The paper argues compellingly that these latter two factors are the ones that really mattered. The study is extensive and complicated, featuring a variety of arcane statistical exercises laid out in fancy regression notation. But many of its main points are captured in this simple chart, depicting the labor-force participation of single women with varying numbers of children.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.