Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Framing issue – Inflation is on the decline – media coverage is lagging – aff evidence is lagging

Cassidy, The New Yorker staff writer, 6-17-23

[John, 6-17-23, The New Yorker, “Why Isn’t Joe Biden Getting More Credit For A Big Drop In Inflation?”, , accessed 7-15-23, EH]

What a difference a year makes. Last June, the inflation rate hit a four-decade high of 9.1 per cent, a development that dominated the news for weeks. At the time, the Federal Reserve was sharply raising interest rates to tackle climbing prices, and many economists were  for this year. Barely able to contain their glee, Republicans were rattling on about “Bidenflation,” even though some of the main factors driving the rise in prices had little or nothing to do with the President (the  and the , to name two).

On Tuesday, however, the Bureau of Labor Statistics announced that the rate of inflation fell to four per cent last month. After declining for eleven months in a row, it has dropped by more than half from last year’s peak. Huge news, right? Apparently not. The inflation report didn’t make the front page of Wednesday’s Times, which was focussed on  in Miami. The Wall Street Journal did put the inflation story on the front page, but it wasn’t the lead: that, too, was Trump. The news networks, meanwhile, sent their anchors to Florida, and covered the inflation figure as a secondary development.

It’s not every day that a former President —even though, with this former President, it is beginning to feel . But the eclipse of the inflation figure is emblematic of a larger story, which is that the U.S. economy has done a lot better in the past year than most experts expected. This development, however, has largely failed to penetrate the public consciousness. With inflation down and unemployment at 3.7 per cent, the so-called misery index, which combines these two rates, is at 7.7 per cent. In January, 2021, when Joe Biden was inaugurated, the misery index was also at 7.7 per cent. (The inflation rate was 1.4 per cent and the unemployment rate was 6.3 per cent.) And, yet, according to the RealClearPolitics poll average, Biden’s approval rating has dropped from above fifty per cent during the first months of his Presidency to just 37.6 per cent now, with a disapproval rating of fifty-nine per cent. This is a disconnect that demands an explanation.

Economists often talk about lags in policy. It takes a while for changes in interest rates or taxes to feed through to the economy, but there are lags in public perception of the economy’s health, too. Although inflation has been falling for nearly a year, the process has been gradual, and people may be only starting to notice. In two of the past seven polls in the R.C.P. database, Biden’s economic approval has edged up into the forties. That could conceivably be the start of a trend, but it would take a brave person to bet on it.

This is largely because, despite the inflation rate falling over all in the past year, many individual prices still remain considerably higher than they were when Biden took office. “Economists tend to look at the rate of change of prices, rather than price levels,” Bernard Yaros, an economist at Moody’s Analytics, told me, on Friday. “Inflation is important, partly because it helps determine what the Federal Reserve will do. But most people tend to look at price levels. And, if you look at levels, it’s understandable why households are still downbeat.”

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.