Increased monetary policy motivates tech innovation
Moran, M.Phil., Economics, University of Oxford, Queralto, , Ph.D., Economics, New York University, 2017 Patrick Moran, M.Phil., Economics, University of Oxford, and Albert Queralto, Ph.D., Economics, New York University, November 2017, International Finance Discussion Papers, “Innovation, Productivity, and Monetary Policy”, https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/ifdp/files/ifdp1217.pdf DOA 7-3-23 [DD}
Growth in total factor productivity (TFP) has slowed dramatically in recent years: as
seen in Figure 1, U.S. TFP growth in the post-1980s has never been as low for as long as
during the post-2007 period.1 This development has been a cause of widespread concern,
and at the same time has sparked an intense debate on its possible causes, with the role of
innovation and business dynamism the subject of increasing attention.2 From the vantage of
monetary policymakers, an important open question is to what extent can monetary policy
exert influence on TFP.
This paper analyzes the link between monetary policy and TFP dynamics using a New
Keynesian model that endogenizes TFP. In the model, technology innovation and adoption
drive medium-run swings in TFP.3 We begin by illustrating how monetary policy in the model
works to induce medium-run movements in TFP, through its impact on firms’ incentives to
develop innovations and implement them in production. We then use the model to address
two specific questions. First, we ask to what extent the zero lower bound (ZLB) constraint
on monetary policy played a role in driving the weakness in TFP growth seen since the onset
of the Great Recession. Second, we examine how much future monetary policy can influence
future TFP, by tightening more slowly than currently projected.
Our findings suggest, first, that the adverse impact of the ZLB on TFP was substantial.
In particular, the constraints imposed by the lower bound on monetary policy from 2009
to 2015 led the levels of TFP and output to be permanently lower by 1.75 percent and
2.5 percent, respectively. Thus, according to our model, the ZLB accounts for a significant
fraction of the TFP and output shortfall relative to pre-crisis projections. Second, we find
that slower tightening of monetary policy after 2016 may significantly enhance longer-run
TFP and output. In particular, an alternative path for the policy rate which reaches the
long-run level of 3 percent around 2025 (rather than in 2019 as under current projections)
results in a boost in long-run TFP of 1 percent, and in long-run GDP of 1.5 percent.
An important aspect of our analysis is the use of identified vector autoregressions (VARs)
to obtain estimates of the dynamic effects of innovation (as measured by aggregate private
R&D expenditure) on TFP dynamics. These estimates indicate that increases in R&D in
the data tend to induce gradual, persistent increases in TFP, consistent with the model’s
predictions. The VAR evidence then proves useful to identify key model parameters linking
innovation and TFP. In addition, our analysis also employs identified VARs as a check on
the model’s empirical plausibility. We do this in two ways. First, we document the dynamic
effects of R&D in a larger-scale VAR (including a set of standard macroeconomic variables)
and compare them against the model’s predictions. Second, we examine the dynamic effects of
monetary policy in a VAR which, in addition to standard macroeconomic variables, includes
both R&D spending and TFP, and also compare the resulting estimates against the model’s
predicted effects of monetary policy shocks. Here, VAR-based estimates of the effects of
monetary policy shocks point to a rise in both R&D and in medium-run TFP following an
expansionary monetary shock, consistent with the model. Overall, the model does reasonably
well on both fronts.