Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Monetary federalism works in small instances, but in entities with many states creates instability that crashes federal currency valuation-empirics prove

Theret, professor at Paris Dauphine-PSL University, 2018 (Bruno, Monetary federalism as а concept and its еmpirical underpinnings in Argentina’s monetary history, MONETARY AND ECONOMIC RESEARCH CENTER 4 th ANNUAL CONFERENCE NEW REALITIES IN THE EU AND THE PLACE OF BALKAN COUNTRIES 11-12 October 2018, .p.30-31, https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Nikolay-Nenovsky/publication/346538778_Monetray_Research_Center_Annual_Book_2018/links/5fc6780f45851568d131ffdf/Monetray-Research-Center-Annual-Book-2018.pdf#page=5)-TL

In most federations, federal tax transfers are of three kinds: general revenue sharing (equalization); earmarked for a particular use ; purely discretionary. But in Argentina the boundaries between these categories are blurred, since, even when fixed rules of automatic revenue sharing and/or earmarking are edicted, it is recurrent that these rules are either bypassed through bilateral negociations between the federal President and Governors, or permanently renegociated. Before the updated institutionalization of revenue-sharing in the Act of coparticipacion of 1988, bypassing federal rules was dominating; afterwards, it has been permanent renegociation of these rules (Bonvecchi 2005). For these reasons provinces suffer a great instability and uncertainty concerning the true amount of federal money they are going to receive annually, monthly, daily. Permanent discussions about the effective amounts of federal engagements is coupled with federal discretion relative to the agenda of payments, since funds distribution is often conditioned to political support to the President’s initiatives in Congress (Bernadou 2009). This uncertainty is increased when the federal government is itself the prey of a fiscal crisis. Moreover money shortage is a daily problem for Provinces since transfers’ payments tend to feed provincial treasuries at irregular pace. In fact federal transfers and devolution of public spendings to provinces are often the primary variables of adjustment in the management of the Nacion federal budget. And because the argentinian economy knows a high degree of volatility and strong dependance vis-à-vis external shocks, federal and then provincial fiscal crises are recurrently expected and always feared Thus it is no surprise in Argentina to see payments of wages to public employees and/or debts visà-vis small providers belated and delayed for months. It is not surprising too to see these waiting periods correlated with social unrests and emergency situations where provincial governments have to borrow money to banks and/or on financial markets, in order to finance current spendings. This large dependance of provincial governments on federal resources explains that their public debt is primarily a floating debt that is funded at high cost.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.