UBI forcibly takes money from taxpayers under a threat of punishment
Reed 22 [Garry, “Universal Basic Income is Universal Theft,” October 12, https://soapboxie.com/us-politics/Universal-Basic-Income-is-Universal-Basic-Theft EP]
But let’s begin at the beginning. Universal Basic Income (UBI) is, according to Wikipedia definition at least, “a form of social security in which all citizens or residents of a country regularly receive an unconditional sum of money, either from a government or some other public institution, in addition to any income received from elsewhere.”
Repeat: “In addition to any income received from elsewhere.” That means in addition to redistributing money forcibly confiscated from taxpayers to benefit people who are truly needy, it also means that thieves, robbers, gangsters, sex traffickers, murderers for hire and mafia-made men will also be collecting loot from taxpayers.
Dolan, in his rebuttal article, explains how some people with “libertarian sympathies” justify the idea of government forcibly redistributing incomes from people who have earned them to people who have not earned them this way:
“By some calculations, the government already spends enough on poverty programs to raise all low-income families to the official poverty level, even though the poverty rate barely budges from year to year. Wouldn’t it be better to spend that money in a way that helps poor people more effectively?”
Translation: Government’s “right” to collect taxes from its citizens under threat of punishment is a given; the only question is figuring out how to redistribute the loot in order to maximize voter support for the redistributors.
The politically-connected have always made their living from taxes.
UBI Taxation Is Theft
This doesn’t exactly align with the fact that the majority of modern libertarians understand that taxation is theft. As Joshua Paladino put it in a Being Libertarian article, “When it comes to universal basic income, libertarians somehow forget their principles. Theft suddenly becomes legitimate under the cloak of efficiency, and the redistribution of wealth becomes a worthy goal because UBI could actually make it happen.”
Governments, throughout history and around the world, support their elitist rulers by forcibly extracting human capital (i.e., taxes) through coercion, intimidation and fraud.
“human capital noun The skills, knowledge, and experience possessed by an individual or population, viewed in terms of their value or cost to an organization or country.” – Oxford Dictionary