Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

UBI is an ethical form of redistribution, it benefits the well being of the worst off.

Amanov, University of Szeged Business and Management MA, 2022 [Shamsaddin, 2022, “The Right to Exist: The Position of Universal Basic Income in the Works of the Most Influential Contemporary Philosophers,” https://philpapers.org/archive/AMATRT.pdf, Accessed 6/30/23, EP]

Today, a middle or upper-class person who does not need UBI may ignore the concept. However, if the same person were asked to build a new just society without knowing his or her position, he or she would not be too reckless about UBI as he or she was before the experiment. Here we observe a behavioral transformation in the approach to UBI and justice in general. The individual's self-interest (starting to consider UBI in the next unknown society) may also play a role in these circumstances. A Turkish proverb, “bana dokunmayan yılan bin yıl yaşasın,”6 is a significant sociological and psychological analysis related to the example. When the snake starts biting, that is another case to evaluate.

Immanuel Kant also mentions careful thinking when it comes to moral decisions. Kant is a philosopher who advocates for a particularly severe view of the role of emotions in moral life (Rohlf, 2013; Warburton, 2011). For Immanuel Kant, one should decide what is moral and immoral based on the principles of “kategorischer Imperativ”7 . From a Kantian perspective, if anyone supports Universal Basic Income as they feel pity or sadness for poor people, this is not an ethical standpoint. The proper ethical standpoint should not derive from emotion but a rational mind and the responsibility of duties.

In the "utopian" world of John Rawls, Universal Basic Income can be one element out of many options to restore justice. If nobody knows their position in the new society, many people, far more than the current number, would be interested in supporting UBI. The feeling of guaranteed basic income and secure life in the hypothetical world would attract many people who do not know what will happen next. However, it is fair to assume that this decision-making and rationalization process does not occur in real-life scenarios.

Another aspect of Rawlsian theory and UBI is that Rawls argued for the well-being of the worst-off group. UBI is for everyone, but UBI is crucial for people in the least advantaged positions in society. Thus, UBI is a suitable policy for the Rawlsian theory of improvement of the condition of 6 Literal translation: a snake that does not touch me may live a thousand years. In this particular saying, a snake is a metaphor for the concept of “danger” or “problem” and is not related to any type of animal cruelty. 7 Categorical Imperative 22 the worst-off group. Rawls (1999b) determined that inequality in the economic difference due to natural talents and abilities can be allowed as long as the worst-off group is in fair conditions and benefits from this situation to some degree. The Difference Principle of John Rawls allows inequalities in wealth and income.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.