Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

China is quickly rising – will soon surpass the U.S. as world leader in innovation

Ian Clay and Robert D. Atkinson, widely published author, ‘23, January 23, “Wake Up, America: China Is Overtaking the United States in Innovation Capacity,” INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY & INNOVATION FOUNDATION, accessed June 29, 2023, https://itif.org/publications/2023/01/23/wake-up-america-china-is-overtaking-the-united-states-in-innovation-capacity/

Many U.S. elites comfort themselves with the narrative that China, at least under the leadership of Xi Jinping, cannot truly innovate and that the U.S. therefore has little to worry about. But this view is premised on too-narrow a view of innovation, largely one referring to the development of science-based, new-to-the-world products. Not only is this definition too narrow for assessing advanced-industry strength, but it is also not clear that this still even rings true given China’s recent gains in areas such as space exploration, genomics, AI, and quantum computing.

Much of the discussion of China’s capabilities is on a proportional basis, which is surely important for determining how innovation-based an economy is. Indeed, if only total capabilities mattered, nations such as Taiwan, Israel, and Singapore could be ignored when it comes to innovation. But even here, China is performing well, not having yet caught up to the United States but being poised to do so within the next decade or so. This is especially true if the United States remains tethered to the status quo of laissez faire ideology on the right and anti-corporate populism on the left.

However, to the extent the two nations engage in geopolitical conflict—military or civilian—it is total, not proportional, innovation that is likely the determining factor. On this factor, it is clear: China significantly leads the United States. Of course, much of that is because China has 4.3 times the population of the United States. But it is also because China’s economy has gained in market share in advanced industries, while the United States has been losing it.

Furthermore, even in areas where China still lags behind the United States by a wide margin, such as with researchers as a share of the workforce and cross-border IP receipts as a share of total exports, progress was consistent and/or rapid. And in areas where China appears to have made little to no progress, such as doctorate degrees awarded per capita, some added context paints China’s position relative to the United States in a more positive light. China is not without its challenges: Its demographic problem and historic reliance on debt-financed investments coupled with its falling productivity growth are not to be written off. However, China is investing in and developing technologies such as industrial robots and high-performance computers that stand to help it face these issues.

Overall, the previous decade was a success for China with respect to innovation and technological catch-up with the United States. The key question for U.S. policymakers is not whether China will continue to make gains relative to the United States when it comes to innovation and advanced production (that depends in large part on U.S. actions) but whether policymakers will make this challenge the central organizing principle for U.S. economic and technology policy. Doing so requires the kinds of national organization and commitment America has been able to muster in the past, from Hamilton’s efforts to become technologically independent from England to Roosevelt’s “arsenal of democracy” to the multi-administration effort to defeat the Soviet Union. In each case, leaders agreed on the challenge and, albeit sometimes with difficulty, mobilized political will and societal and economic resources to respond and win. That is once again America’s challenge. In the next decade, America must decide whether it will meet this challenge or shrink from it.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.