Utopian analysis is necessary to go beyond what we know – UBI can be rigorously scrutinized without every detail – NO plan captures every detail
Philippe Van Parijs, Hoover Chair of Economic and Social Ethics @ University of Louvain, Louvain, Belgium, Nuffield College, Oxford, UK, ’13, “The Universal Basic Income: Why Utopian Thinking Matters, and How Sociologists Can Contribute to It” Politics & Society 41(2) 171–182, accessed June 29, 2023, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/0032329213483106
The objective of this utopian thinking must not be to specify all minute details of what a perfect society would look like. It must rather be (1) to formulate proposals for radical reforms to the present social order, (2) to justify these by reference to normative principles or values to which on reflection one is willing to commit, combined with the best possible scientific analysis of the root causes of the problems which the proposals are meant to address, and (3) to subject the proposals to unindulgent critical scrutiny, scanning relentlessly for all possible perverse effects, all to be evaluated in the light of explicit normative considerations. Such utopian thinking is not meant to be value-neutral but it does not make social scientific truth depend on valued judgments. Utopian thinking requires answers to many factual questions about likely effects, about compatibility, about sustainability. It is perfectly legitimate for the choice of these factual questions to be guided by value judgments, but it is essential that the answers to these questions be shielded from the inference of both our interests and our values. Utopian thinking is not to be confused with wishful thinking. It requires tough disciplining by a demanding, multidisciplinary scientific community in order to dissuade us from believing and asserting what we would like to be true but is not. This crucial demand of intellectual integrity, however, should never make us shy away from our collective mission of helping design a better yet feasible future, of helping give hope, reasonable hope to our generation and generations to come, of fashioning realistic utopias.