Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

UBI trade-offs are beneficial – their link concedes funding exists

Worstall 2016’

[Tim, June 4 2016, Forbes, “Of Course We Can Afford A Universal Basic Income: Do We Want One Though?,” , date accessed 6/24, DG]

June 4 2016 One of the arguments against a universal basic income is that we can't actually afford one. Whatever amount that we were able to pay to everyone simply wouldn't be large enough to actually cover the basics of life. Well, not without pushing up taxation levels to unsupportable levels. This isn't in fact true: we can indeed afford a UBI at an entirely reasonable level within the confines of the amount that we already tax. So thus the question moves on to the next point: do we actually want one? At which point I say yes, obviously we do, as I have been saying for some years now. Simply on the basis that a UBI would be vastly better than the cruel, almost wicked, welfare states that we currently have. Which brings us to the calculation of how we can indeed afford a UBI. Charles Murray is in the WSJ today: In my version, every American citizen age 21 and older would get a $13,000 annual grant deposited electronically into a bank account in monthly installments. Three thousand dollars must be used for health insurance (a complicated provision I won’t try to explain here), leaving every adult with $10,000 in disposable annual income for the rest of their lives. There is no increment for children. From Murray's earlier book (which I think is being released in updated form soon) I recall that the argument here was interesting. A UBI requires that no one insist upon how you live your life. Here's your income, use it as you wish. If that includes having children then fine, if it includes not doing so then fine also. The point being that we really are trying to maximise human freedom here, even while making sure that all can at least eat. And if we're maximising freedom to do whatever you want then we can't go around changing how much you get because of what you do. It's possible that you think $13,000 a year isn't enough. It's certainly not going to be a plush lifestyle by American standards, not when someone decides to do no work at all to top it up. But it's also true that $13,000 a year puts you in the top 12% of all global income earners. It would be nicer if there was some more significant digit there, like $13k puts you into the global 10% or something, but that does seem a fair enough guarantee to get purely through the privilege of having been born an American. There's two issues which also get entirely solved by such a plan, over and above our destruction of the current welfare state....and as Murray points out, we would indeed destroy that: The UBI is to be financed by getting rid of Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, food stamps, Supplemental Security Income, housing subsidies, welfare for single women and every other kind of welfare and social-services program, as well as agricultural subsidies and corporate welfare. As of 2014, the annual cost of a UBI would have been about $200 billion cheaper than the current system. By 2020, it would be nearly a trillion dollars cheaper. A UBI at this level is actually cheaper than the current system.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.