UBI fosters entrepreneurial spirits
Jason Francis D’Mello, Ph.D. Associate Professor of Entrepreneurship at Loyola Marymount University. Universal Basic Income and Entrepreneurial Pursuit in an Autonomous Society. Journal of Management Inquiry 2019, Vol. 28(3) 306–310. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/1056492619827381?casa_token=SS80O_OpY6QAAAAA:wWuHeQl3hmwJe6pyJtXEPdBLgwY84JimCDLeU6fFkiEZ4g9XMql5KuDSzbLXQD0ZziVtiGQ4RdM. AR.
At issue is how this research on motivations relates to our hypothetical scenario with UBI and entrepreneurial behavior? Productivity, performance, and perseverance are outcomes of motivations that come from within the individual, not from external rewards (Deci, 1976; Steers, Mowday, & Shapiro, 2004). A study on the motivations of individual innovators found that intrinsic motivations were indicated by joy of work, confidence, autonomy, and duty and were critical during the early stage of a venture (Bhaduri & Kumar, 2011). In other words, the motivation was driven by the purpose found in the work itself. In a world of automation and its impending disruption of employment for the masses, it is 308 Journal of Management Inquiry 28(3) highly likely that people will have to depend on alternative means of support for their subsistence. Could UBI be the answer? And for those bitten by the entrepreneurial bug, could UBI actually be the saving grace, helping them to get by and freeing them up to pursue their entrepreneurial creativity? One analogy to such a system is that of a base salary plus commission compensation plan that has proven to be very successful in the sales world. Can UBI provide the safety net for the entrepreneurial community to have the freedom to pursue their dreams? This is an empirical question worthy of further research and discourse. Entrepreneurial Intentions There are many examples of entrepreneurs who find incredible successes to the tune of billions of dollars of wealth, only to pledge to give the majority of their earnings away. The wealth appears to possibly serve as a mechanism for “keeping score” more than the motivation to build the business. Also, within the entrepreneurship literature, there are several examples of the importance of nonmonetary rewards as motivators for entrepreneurial action (Andersson, 2008; Baron, Franklin, & Hmieleski, 2016; Parker, 2009; Uy, Foo, & Song, 2013). These nonpecuniary benefits of entrepreneurship are found through the autonomy and satisfaction with the work and range of possibilities to apply an individual’s skills and abilities, leading to richer experiences in his or her work. In fact, one study found that founders of innovative, high-growth firms financed by venture-capital funds were willing to work for lower incomes than other, nonfounding executives employed at the same firms, even after controlling for level of stock and stock option ownership (Wasserman, 2004). A quick glance at research on creativity and modern innovation communities shows similar patterns. At an organizational level, teamwork, autonomy, domain-relevant competencies, inclusiveness, fair processes, and practices all positively support satisfaction with creativity in the workplace. Individually, similar to previous research cited, the strength of intrinsic motivations enhances satisfaction with creativity (Sacchetti & Tortia, 2013). Other research on creativity finds that the types of value priorities (self-direction) and intrinsic motivational orientation (Kasof, Chen, Himsel, & Greenberger, 2007) influence creative behavior. Consider the musician in our modern society. This creative pursuit requires deeper motivation than reward incentives. The odds of finding success are quite rare with nearly one million composers, songwriters, and music publishers registered on either American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers (ASCAP) or Broadcast Music, Inc. (BMI). According to these two leading performance rights organizations, over one million songs are written, recorded, and released each year, yet very few artists are able to earn a sustainable living off their work. The motivation for artists to be creative is an intrinsic one, and these artists continue their pursuits regardless of being able to earn a living from their art. Perhaps UBI could be the solution to enable entrepreneurs to remain gainfully engaged and in pursuit of their dreams in a world where jobs would be hard to come by! Peer-Production and Open-Source Communities Our modern society is also ripe with examples of innovation without profit, found through peer production or a form of open creation and sharing performed by groups online in a decentralized manner (Benkler, Shaw, & Hill, 2015). These open-source communities include participants with diverse, nonmonetary motivations, separate governance comprised of participatory, meritocratic, and charismatic models instead of traditional contractual or proprietary systems (Benkler et al., 2015). The platforms are also typically free, such as Wikipedia, GNU/Linux, Apache web server, and the cyberpunk movement credited for developing the recently popularized blockchain technology. These peer-production platforms directly challenge conventional economic theories of motivation and cooperation because they offer no clear extrinsic incentives (Benkler et al., 2015). Highly skilled individuals continue to contribute without monetary rewards. Research suggests that the motivations to participate in these communities include the value of the software to the developer, hedonic pleasure of building software, increased human capital, reputation, employment prospects, and social status within a community of peers, reciprocity, sense of efficacy, and collective identity (Benkler et al., 2015; Ghosh, 1998; Kollock, 1999; Lerner & Tirole, 2002; von Hippel & von Krogh, 2003; von Krogh, 2003). These intrinsic and sociopsychological motivators may be similar to the motivators of our future entrepreneur existing within a UBI society in which traditional monetary rewards may cease to exist. Privileges in Entrepreneurship Despite the wide range of research topics found in entrepreneurship, few scholars have adequately discussed privilege as being an antecedent to the choice to engage in entrepreneurial activity. Yet, the data indicate that wealth, race, and family background are often significant drivers of entrepreneurial activity (Blanchflower & Oswald, 1998). Levine and Rubinstein (2017) point out that that entrepreneurs tend to be male, White, better educated and more likely to come from high-earning, two-parent families (Levine & Rubinstein, 2017). Moreover, with over US$1.4 trillion of student loan debt, economic privileges may continue to factor into selfemployment decisions (Morelix, 2015). Privilege in entrepreneurship has also been researched among those who transition late in their careers. For individuals aged 50 years or above, a transition into entrepreneurship significantly increases the quality of life measured by needs of control autonomy, self-realization, and pleasure, while at the same time offering a significant reduction in income (Kautonen, Kibler, & Minniti, 2017). Clearly, not everyone at this age is afforded such an opportunity due to limitations of health, family obligations, and other economic constraints. This study gives supporting evidence to a popular perspective that those who can take entrepreneurial risks today enjoy a certain level of privilege. Other work related to reentry into entrepreneurship after previous failures supports this notion that there are certain individuals who may have a safety net, or access to capital to allow for certain risks to be taken during their pursuit of opportunities. There are certainly also entrepreneurs who emerge out of necessity, being forced into self-employment due to adverse conditions. However, this discussion focuses on opportunity entrepreneurs, who choose self-employment voluntarily. UBI may offer more individuals with entrepreneurial intentions new privileges to take on action on their ideas by increasing their ranges of affordable loss. By acknowledging entrepreneurial privilege, I am not necessarily dismissing the grit, perseverance, resilience, tenacity, innovativeness, resourcefulness, leadership, vision, and other crucial qualities that these entrepreneurs may have. However, I suggest that there is a strong possibility that other individuals, less privileged in our current society, may also possess and discover similar qualities that could allow them, too, to thrive during the process of pursuing opportunities (even if some ventures resulted in failures). These individuals lack the privileges found among those who are self-employed in our labor economic research, such as an inheritance, family wealth, access to capital, and other advantages that reduce the risk of not being able to meet basic survival needs. The “rags to riches” narrative that claims that anyone can become an entrepreneur in our society does not quite align with the research on who actually chooses to become self-employed. Entrepreneurial privilege seems to currently determine who gets to play (and stay) in the game. As automation permeates our world and job losses become widespread, alternative public policy solutions such as UBI will become a distinct possibility. Critics of UBI argue that having such a safety net could demotivate people from becoming productive and lead to inertia. However, it can also be argued that the intrinsic motivation and creative spirit, that is prevalent in our entrepreneurial community, would prevail. With the comfort and freedom from job stress, provided by UBI, one would not need to be privileged to pursue one’s entrepreneurial dream! UBI may offer a wider safety net for more entrepreneurs to be productive within our society regardless of the monetary rewards of their pursuits. Social psychology literature on motivations offers strong evidence that human motivation can persist in a world where income is universal as long as there is meaning found in being actively engaged. As the labor market shrinks, new markets may emerge. Peerproduction and open-source communities may serve as the motivators for these types of markets. Reputational capital, status, identity, and other intrinsic motivators may bring a similar sense of purpose to individual lives as our current monetary wealth does. It is difficult to predict what types of consumer demand, customer pain points, or social problems our future world may face. However, looking at the history of human behavior, motivations, innovations, and social relations, there may certainly be a positive outcome from entrepreneurs collaborating and creating in new ways that meet a higher order of needs than what we may understand today. These advances will create more opportunities and give purpose to the ambitious individual. While it remains to be seen what specific activities will occupy the future entrepreneur’s time, I have confidence that he or she will share the same empathy, imagination, and ingenuity as the entrepreneurs we know today to recognize unmet needs and creatively solve the problems they discover to be entrepreneurial opportunities. In conclusion, I argue that as long as humans have the freedom to dream and imagine a more hopeful future while believing that their behavior can impact the world around them in a positive way, entrepreneurship will live on and may thrive even in an unexpected environment.