UBI better then EITC—4 key reasons
Kasy, Associate Professor, Department of Economics, Harvard University, 18’
[Maximilian, 8-5-2018, Pg. 20, Harvard Kennedy School Mossavar-rahmani Center for Business and Government, “Why a Universal Basic Income Is Better Than Subsidies of Low-Wage Work,” https://www.hks.harvard.edu/centers/mrcbg/programs/growthpolicy/why-universal-basic-income-better-subsidies-low-wage-work, 6/27, DG]
In this paper, we compare two types of transfers: subsidies of low-wage work, like the existing Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC), and unconditional transfers, such as the hypothetical Universal Basic Income (UBI). We discuss several arguments for unconditional transfers. 1. Negative marginal tax rates are bad for both efficiency and equity: a. When marginal tax rates are positive, we have to take more than $1 from someone rich to give $1 to someone less rich, reflecting a tradeoff between efficiency and equity (“leaky bucket”). b. When marginal tax rates are negative, as under the EITC, we have to take less than $1 from someone with income to give $1 to someone without any income, by eliminating the distortion to supply too much labor (“magic bucket”). c. Going from the EITC toward an equally generous UBI would therefore improve both efficiency and equity. 2. Subsidizing increased labor supply hurts other workers: a. Subsidizing low-wage labor supply depresses wages. The subsidy is, at least in part, a transfer to employers rather than to low-income earners. b. If there is unemployment, subsidizing low-wage work increases competition for a limited number of jobs and increases search times and search costs for all workers—rather than increasing employment. 3. Fairness, justice, liberty: a. A UBI contributes to a society in which everyone is entitled to a basic level of dignity, safety, and liberty, free from material fear and personal dependence on abusive partners, overbearing welfare bureaucrats, or exploitative bosses. b. A UBI provides remuneration for the numerous unpaid activities a functioning society relies on—including, for example, care for children and the elderly, political and community involvement, and artistic and cultural production. 4. UBI might enjoy more stable support than narrowly targeted transfers: a. Narrowly targeted transfers are often stigmatized and have a limited political constituency to support and defend them. b. By contrast, broad-based transfers (e.g., Social Security or Medicare in the U.S.) enjoy stable and broad popular support and experience less political volatility. If appropriately framed, the same might ultimately be true for a UBI.