Universal payments key to prevent stigma – prerequisite for solvency
Hilary W. Hoynes, Richard & Rhoda Goldman School of Public Policy, and Jesse Rothstein Goldman School of Public Policy and Department of Economics, ‘19, February, “UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME IN THE US AND ADVANCED COUNTRIES,” Working Paper 25538, https://gspp.berkeley.edu/assets/uploads/research/pdf/w25538.pdf
There may be political value in the universal aspect of a UBI, as a way of maintaining widespread support for the program (e.g. as with universal programs such as social security and Medicare) and as a way of signaling social inclusion and that everyone is valued (Lowrey 2018). If this argument has merit, it has implications for program design and the taxes needed to pay for it. A tax on non-UBI income effectively becomes a program phase-out. But separating out the program, and maintaining universality, from the taxes needed to pay for it, may be advantageous even if irrelevant from an accounting perspective.
Another implication of universality, related to potential impacts on social inclusion, is a lack of stigma for UBI recipients. In highly means tested and eligibility-restricted programs, participation reveals information that many consider private, and thus may be stigmatized. This reduces program take-up and the potential reach and benefits of programs (Currie 2006), though may also help target the programs, maximizing impact by reaching those who stand to benefit the most. Take-up rates in AFDC were quite low (about 50%) with stigma cited as one of the reasons (Moffitt 1983). Interestingly, the EITC has fairly high take-up rates (80% or more, see Scholz 1994, Plueger 2009), and ethnographic research has found low stigma with recipients viewing the credit as “my work bonus” rather than a handout (Halpern-Meekin, Edin, Tach and Sykes 2015). How much this derives from the “in work” nature of the credit (G=0) or its high P relative to other U.S. means-tested programs is not known. The UBI could lead to similar results given a universal structure.