3. Their ev does not assume fiat – don’t give UBI the benefit of the doubt, best-case scenario is massive taxation
Cowan, Policy and Politics Media Commentator, 17 [Simon, November 2017, The Centre for Independent Studies, “Ubi – Universal Basic Income is an Unbelievably Bad Idea”, https://www.cis.org.au/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/rr32.pdf, accessed 6/25/2023, S.P.]
However all these experiments share a single flaw, which causes them to systematically underestimate the disincentive impact of a UBI. None of the experiments address how a UBI would be funded. This means that none of the participants in the trial communities have to pay extra tax, so none of the taxation disincentive effects inherent in a UBI are included. Given the likely enormous cost of implementing a UBI, substantial additional taxation would be required. As Samuel Hammond puts it “Taxes and transfers are two sides of the same coin … to propose a lump sum transfer like UBI without an explicit discussion of how it’s financed only tells half the story.”70 He goes on to conclude “universal transfer programs like a Basic Income cannot be analysed outside of the tax system that pays for it.”71 Once the cost of a universal style UBI is calculated, it becomes clear just how important it is to factor this in.