UBI hurts the workforce – their arguments for solving inequality and worker conditions GRANT that many employees will credibly threaten to quit
Dan Schawbel, New York Times best-selling author and managing partner of Workplace Intelligence, ’20, January 1, “How Universal Basic Income Would Impact the Future of Work and Careers,” https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/how-universal-basic-income-would-impact-future-work-careers-schawbel
The reason why there is almost a complete split between American's on UBI is that there are benefits and drawbacks to the government program. The biggest benefits of the UBI social safety net include mental health improvements, bringing people out of poverty, addressing income inequality, promoting social inclusion, reducing homelessness, and stimulating entrepreneurship. As I spoke about earlier with Yang, UBI allows workers to make better employment decisions because it gives them the financial backing to quit a toxic manager, pursue a new career, or start a business. It's easier to follow your passion when there's money to lean on because many ideas fail. In this way, UBI would put pressure on employers to treat their workers better because they would lose leverage and have a harder time competing for talent when talent has more freedom through financial safety.
Although UBI poses some tremendous life-altering and society-improving benefits, there are several drawbacks that should be considered when evaluating it. These include potentially encouraging laziness, discouraging part-time work, higher taxes, and welfare for people like criminals.
Other countries are testing UBI
Switzerland's UBI experiment influenced other European countries like Finland. In 2017, the Finnish government offering a trial run of UBI with a guaranteed tax-free income of $590 a month to two thousand random citizens. The experiment was deemed a failure because UBI recipients were no more likely to get a job than those who didn't receive it. But, they did find that those receiving UBI were happier and more confident compared to those in the control group. Despite this failure, more citizens in European countries compared to America support UBI. A study found that across the EU14, 46 percent support it compared to 29 percent who don't.
During this pandemic, several countries have either implemented some form of UBI or are considering it because they view it as a solution to protect citizens from poverty and homelessness while maintaining their economies. Canada's Emergency Response Benefit (CERB) provides $2,000 monthly payments to seasonal workers, gig workers, students, and others deprived of income after they apply for it and are accepted. Spain is planning to roll out UBI to about a million of its poorest citizens during the pandemic. The government is offering job search incentives, like the ability to combine UBI with wages from a new job for a period of time, so they don't make the same mistake as Finland. Kenya is testing the largest UBI experiment with 20,000 random citizens, with the first group receiving the full UBI as a lump sum, the second group of those 18 years old or older receiving $22 each month for two years and the third group of adults receiving $22 each month for twelve years.
Some governments are pushing back against UBI. Even though Scotland's First Minister Nicola Sturgeon said UBI's "time has come", they are part of the UK which rejects the idea. “Universal basic income is an issue that’s being tested in other countries and hasn’t been taken forward," said UK Business Secretary Alok Sharma. Still, the more UBI is covered in the media, and the more countries that experiment with it, eventually there will be a stronger, more sustainable solution that may have mass adoption, but we don't know if that will happen, when it will happen and what the end result will be.
UBI and the future of work
The pandemic, which led to this recession, has forced leaders to come up with solutions. UBI is a potential old solution to a new problem that we face as a society. UBI really boils down to having a stronger social safety net so citizens can survive and thrive in the new world of work and have some resemblance and chance at creating their own American dream. Much like all workplace trends and movements, UBI has been most evangelized in Silicon Valley, yet has become a global conversation uplifted by Yang. As I mentioned, Zuckerberg believes in UBI as a remedy to our crisis and announced that his 45,000 employees will receive an additional $1,000 bonus during these tough times. Much like the CARES Act bill, this is only a one-time payment but similar to the bill, neither our government nor any company has performed this act during a pandemic. These examples show citizens what's possible and may inspire additional payments in the future.
If the future of work includes a UBI safety net, there would be a massive power shift, giving employees more leverage than ever before - a constant seller's market. And, more leverage forces companies to be more competitive for talent, which in turn creates a healthier work environment. You are more likely to quit your job or switch jobs when you are confident that you can pay your bills. You are more likely to start a business if you have money to invest in it, and a safety net to fall back into if it fails. Guaranteed income outside of employment gives workers freedom - the freedom to make employment decisions based on their passions, interests, and skillset. Think about how game-changing a strong social safety would be in a world where 80 percent of workers dislike their jobs. Whether UBI comes to fruition or not, more money for workers means a revival of the American Dream and actually being able to follow your passion, not just consuming Instagram quotes telling you to.