Elections DA Link – UBI unpopular even among liberals
Lee, University of La Verne, Public Administration, Professor 21
[Soomi Lee, 2021, Basic Income Studies Vol.16 (2), “Politics of Universal and Unconditional Cash Transfer: Examining Attitudes Toward Universal Basic Income,” , Accessed: 06-24-23, CV]
Since universalism is a built-in feature of UBI, people who support universal social benefits are expected to be more supportive of UBI. The analysis shows the opposite. People who believe that social benefits should be provided only to the lowest income group are more likely to support UBI. The result is consistent with findings in Roosma and Van Oorschot (2019). It is puzzling why strong preferences for universalism do not increase support for UBI. There are a few potential explanations. First, “social benefits and services” in the survey questionnaire are open to interpretation. Some people may consider social benefits only as cash transfers while others as cash and in-kind benefits (e.g. universal healthcare). In other words, people might support the universal provision of public education and universal healthcare but not for cash assistance. Thus, even when people support universal in-kind transfers, they may not necessarily support a universal cash transfer program such as UBI. Second, people perceive UBI as a complementary program to current poverty alleviation programs, although researchers and policymakers consider it as a radical alternative that could transform flawed current welfare programs. Europeans may construe a UBI policy as one of the programs that they are familiar with. Roosma and Van Oorschot (2019) conjecture that “[t]hismay be related to the fact that the so-called path dependency of welfare institutions is stronger in more developed welfare states, with the result that it will be more difficult to gather support for a radical alternative such as [U]BI (p. 6).” Alternatively, it is possible that respondents do not understand Figure 1: Marginal effects of preference for universal benefits on attitudes toward redistribution and UBI. Dashed lines indicate 95% confidence intervals. Politics of Universal Basic Income 201 UBI’s universalism. However, the speculations are difficult to be tested due to data limitation.