Would result in a government takeover of the economy
Harsanyi, Federallist senior editor, ‘18
[David Harsanyi, senior editor, The Federalist, “Democrats' Universal Job Plan Would Be a Socialist Disaster,” REASON, 4—27—18, , accessed 6-9-23]
Most of all, making government responsible for every American's job prospects would change the dynamics of governance—forever. Not only would politicians be expected to help create the economic conditions that make growth possible; they would then face another unrealistic expectation. Unemployment would no longer be a function of economic conditions but rather heartless politicians who fail to create jobs for voters.
This is exactly what left-leaning economists who obsess about inequality and push zero-sum fantasies about wealth and growth want. It's why they wanted the federal government to control the structure of the health care system, and it's why they want to create a "public" job option. Most of them openly argue the universal job program would let them control wages and benefits in the private sector.