Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

You should adopt critical consequentialism- examine every possible alternative before taking unethical action. This is the only way to avoid atrocities. Blum, Assistant Professor of Law at Harvard, 2008

[Gabriella, “The Laws of War and the ‘Lesser Evil,’” Harvard Law School Faculty Scholarship Series, Paper 24,http://lsr.nellco.org/harvard/faculty/papers/24, Accessed 7/11/13]

To be truly justified, a net utilitarian calculation is insufficient; the¶ actor, instead, must be able to show that she had chosen the least possible¶ harmful mean that could avert the greater evil, without jeopardizing thesuccess of the military mission. This further condition is intended tosupplement the causal connection between the violation and the aversion ofharm and to ensure that the lesser evil justification is not used to maskunnecessary atrocities.The domestic necessity defense does not require this condition; instead,it offers only a vague proportionality test. The joint necessity-duress clausein the ICC Rome Statute includes a similarly broader test, namely that “theperson acts necessarily and reasonably to avoid this threat.” Both thedomestic necessity and the ICC necessity operate only when the defendanthas acted against an imminent threat. But where a government chooses in annon-imminent, premeditated decision to break the law, it supposedly canand should assess the full ramifications of the violation, including byconsidering less harmful means, whether legal or illegal themselves.In the Early Warning case, the High Court of Justice addressed thepossible use of loudspeakers as an alternative to the reliance on civilians.The IDF’s position, to recall, was that the use of loudspeakers would callattention to the forces operating, thereby increasing the risk of all-roundescalation. It is unclear to what extent this alternative affected the finaldecision of the judges, and whether the Court ultimately struck down theprocedure despite deferring to the IDF’s judgment on this particular issue.The use of torture, so it is commonly agreed by those who are willing toaccept it as necessary under certain circumstances, must be restricted tothose cases where a similar outcome could not be achieved by any othermeans. Consequently, if any less harmful measure (for instance, detention,the taking of hostages, or even the threat of using torture) would have had asimilar probability of success, torture would be unjustifiable.This requirement would also exclude certain atrocities from¶ consideration under the humanitarian necessity paradigm altogether.Consider, for instance, the crime of rape: It is impossible to imagine anyscenario in which the raping of an individual would be the least harmfulway to achieve a certain goal. If anything less than killing is possible, there¶ must be a range of less harmful means to avert the harm the infliction ofwhich is allowed under the law.The less harmful means requirement casts the largest shadow over theattacks on Hiroshima, and particularly, Nagasaki. Was it indeed impossibleto avert Operation Downfall by using less disastrous means? Or were somescientists, who argued that inviting UN representatives for a livedemonstration of the explosion in the desert, correct in arguing that thisoption had to be tried out first, before dropping the bomb on denselypopulated cities? Does the insistence of the Emperor on conditionalsurrender even after the widespread firebombing of Tokyo and the invasionof Okinawa prove that there were no other options? Did the conditions setby the Emperor warrant the continuation of the war? Could the use ofnuclear weapons ever be justified under the “least harmful requirement”condition?

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.