Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Even within their own framing, calculation and utilitarianism are inevitable. Consequences comes first – without them, how can we determine what is ethical?

Chandler ‘14

(David Chandler is Professor of International Relations at the Department of Politics and International Relations, University of Westminster – “Beyond good and evil: Ethics in a world of complexity” – International Politics, Vol. 51, No. 4 (2014), pp.441-457 Available at: http://www.davidchandler.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/International-Politics-Evil-PUBLISHED-2.pdf)

Self-reflexive ethics redistribute responsibility and emphasize the indirect, unintended and relational networks of complex causation. Collective problems are reconceived ontologically: as constitutive of communities and of political purpose. This is why many radical and critical voices in the West are drawn to the problems of 'side effects', of 'second-order' consequences - of a lack of knowledge of the emergent causality at play in the complex interconnections of the global world. The more these interconnections are revealed, though the work of self-reflexivity and self-reflection, the more ethical authority can be regained by governments and other agents of governance. We learn and learn again that we are responsible for the world, not because of our conscious choices or because our actions lacked the right ethical intention, but because the world's complexity is beyond our capacity to know and understand in advance. The unknowability of the outcomes of our action does not remove our ethical responsibility for our actions, it, in fact, heightens our responsibility for these second-order consequences or side effects. In a complex and interconnected world, few events or problems evade appropriation within this framing, providing an opportunity for recasting responsibility in these ways. The new ethics of indirect responsibility for market consequences can be seen (observed) clearly in the idea of environmental taxation, both state-enforced through interventions in the market and as taken up by both firms and individuals. The idea that we should pay a carbon tax on air travel is a leading example of this, in terms of governmental intervention, passing the burden of such problems on to 'unethical' consumers who are not reflexive enough to consider the impact of package holidays on the environment. At a broader level, the personalized ethico-political understanding that individuals should be responsible for and measure their own 'carbon footprint' shifts the emphasis from an understanding of broader inter-relations between modernity, the market and the environment to a much narrower understanding of personal indirect responsibility, linking all aspects of everyday decision making to the problems of global warming (see, for example, Marres, 2012). The shared responsibility for the Breivik murders is not different -ontologically - from the societally shared responsibility for global warming or other problematic appearances in the world. Through our actions and inactions we collectively constitute the frameworks in which others act and make decisions -failing to raise our voice against 'borderline racism' or extremism in a bar makes us indirectly responsible for acts of racism or extremism in the same way that failing to save water or minimize air travel makes us indirectly responsible for the melting polar ice caps.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.