Federal job guarantee removes the threat of unemployment as a coercive tool – increases worker protections and bargaining power
Tcherneva, Bard Economics Associate professor, ‘22
[Pavlina R. Tcherneva, Associate Professor, Economics, Bard College, “Decommodifying Work: The Power of a Job Guarantee,” in Democratize Work : The Case for Reorganizing the Economy, University of Chicago Press, p. 85-88, GDI-MAM]
We work. We participate, care, and provide. We produce and reproduce. In the modern world, much of our work is commodified through private firms organizing production and employment for commercial return. Meanwhile, working people are often underpaid, brave dangerous conditions, and face the constant threat of unemployment. With or without COVID, the labor market is a cruel game of musical chairs in which hundreds of millions of people search fruitlessly for work while millions more endure precarious employment. Unemployment is a powerful, if silent, force of economic injustice. It has undermined the foundations of postwar labor relations, the social contract, and workplace solidarity. It looms in every negotiation between unions and firms and opens the door to job outsourcing, race-to-the-bottom pay practices, and the hiring of cheap migrant labor. The threat of unemployment has been and remains the most powerful coercive tool firms wield over their workers. The lives of the unemployed and the employed are thus shadowed by the same fate—the risk of economic insecurity.
The job guarantee1 proposal aims to end this toxic dynamic by rising to the call of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and securing the right to decent work for all people—and to the dignity it brings. The job guarantee is a centrally funded but locally administered public option for good jobs. It is an employment safety net that creates opportunities for the unemployed in long-neglected areas of public purpose—such as health care, community renewal, and environmental remediation. In the United States, it has been hailed as the single most crucial aspect of the Green New Deal agenda. It is a new labor standard for pay and benefits and an alternative to poverty wages in private-sector jobs. It is a stepping-stone for many job seekers and a powerful anticyclical shock absorber for the economy. The job guarantee offers a new social contract—one in which precarious work, communities in disrepair, and an environment in crisis are no longer acceptable casualties in a market-driven economy.
The job guarantee decommodifies work in several ways. First, it ensures that employment offers—that is, the available paid work opportunities—would not depend exclusively on how financially profitable it is to hire people. This is already true of a significant proportion of jobs: in the public and nonprofit sectors, for example, jobs are created not because they generate financial return but because they serve the larger public interest. This may sound strange in an era when we are all accustomed to capitalism’s relentless focus on financial profitability, but this type of work is widespread in the economy already. It includes the kinds of activities that provide for our most basic needs: accessible transportation, safety, monitoring, quality control, clean air and water, essential infrastructure, public education, theaters, libraries, and health care. This list is an illustration of the extent to which the things we do in the economy are about providing care: we transport, protect, clothe, feed, entertain, heal, and educate one another. But the profit motive has proven to be ineffective in providing adequate and decent care services for all, meaning that these critical areas remain understaffed and underfunded despite their being central to all human existence. The job guarantee helps meet humanity’s neglected needs by matching them to people who can fulfill them.
Second, the job guarantee offers a critical protection for working people. In the modern world, workers (especially those in lowwage jobs) are often treated more poorly than physical or financial commodities. Governments have no trouble intervening quickly in markets to prop up the value of agricultural commodities, oil, and even financial assets when their price drops, rolling out various price supports, buffer stock schemes, and lending programs without batting an eye. Governments are equally responsible for the unemployed, but working people, in contrast to these commodities, are treated as entirely disposable. They are regularly laid off with meager and temporary unemployment protection. A living-wage job guarantee ought to be the minimum necessary employment safety net and protection that governments are obliged to provide, consistent with the objectives of the Universal Declaration.
Third, the job guarantee establishes an uncompromising labor standard for all jobs in the economy, offering dignified employment at family-sustaining wages to anyone who shows up at an unemployment office looking for work. It strengthens the bargaining power of the most vulnerable workers and provides an exit option to working people who experience wage theft, harassment, and discrimination, to name just a few labor market problems. By establishing a secure living-wage floor, below which no working person should fall, the job guarantee pressures private employers to meet and exceed their minimum wage-benefit package to retain and attract workers. Fourth, inoculating against the enormous social and economic costs of unemployment is in the public interest. The research is clear: unemployment is costly. People are weaker, sicker, and more vulnerable when they experience unemployment. Their mortality increases, and the impact is felt over the long term. Spouses and children suffer many ill effects too, from greater mental and physical health problems to growth stunting and poorer educational and labor market outcomes. Indeed, from the way unemployment spreads from community to community after a sudden shock of mass layoffs to its impact on individuals and their families, it is clear that unemployment behaves like an epidemic—quiet, pernicious, deadly. Governments are then left to deal with the fallout. In the name of job creation, they roll out tax cuts, incentives, subsidies, income support programs of one kind or another, training and education, firm contracts, and loan guarantees—none of which actually create enough jobs for all who need them.
The job guarantee is the most straightforward path to a postpandemic recovery and tackling the climate crisis—but it must be a permanent policy. Market economies have a rhythm, growing in expansions and shrinking in recessions, and the collateral damage is always people, who are laid off when sales and profitability drop. Thus, the job guarantee is not just another jobs program; it is a structural macroeconomic policy, a countercyclical employment program that expands with recessions (as unemployed people take up public-service work) and shrinks in expansions (as they transition back to the private sector when employment opportunities recover and become more abundant).
Unemployment is a policy choice. In the universe of economic outcomes, there are only two options—guaranteed unemployment or guaranteed employment—and either way, the public sector foots the bill. While unemployment brings large real and financial costs along with negative productivity, the job guarantee inoculates against these costs and directs public funding toward creating socially useful output and superior economic stability.