GND inspires green growth and innovation to meet demand for tech
Allam et al. 2022 (Zaheer Allam; Research Candidate at the Institute of Sustainable Futures at the University of Technology Sydney, Ayyoob Sharifid, Damien Giurcoa, Samantha A. Sharpe, “Green new deals could be the answer to COP26’s deep decarbonisation Needs,” Sustainable Horizons Volume 1, January 2022, 100006, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.horiz.2022.100006, GDI-MAM)
Green New Deals (GND) can be positioned as a potent model to pursue green growth. It simultaneously pursues economic growth, societal resilience, and community empowerment while addressing the core challenges of sustainability transitions. Regarding this, GNDs can be defined as a resolution agreed by either governments, institutions, or organizations to mobilize different aspects of economies and societies to ensure the transition to cleaner energy, production, and operation of varying human activities while increasing job opportunities for all people via a guarantee for social protection by authorities (Allam et al., 2021). As of 2021, a variety of GNDs existed, varying dynamics. An example of such is the European Union's GND Model illustrated in Figure 1 below, which showcases the breadth of scope that the model can be made to approach. Similarly, other geographies can implement such strategies regarding contextual needs, where policies can be made to respond to localized socio-economic needs while collectively building towards global emissions reduction targets.
The GND concept has gained traction in the last decade, with different regions formulating their versions. However, it is appreciated that the concept started to gain global popularity in 2008 after the United Nations announced a global Green Deal (Barbier, 2009). Following this, former United States President Barack Obama 2008 attempted, with no success, to introduce a GND for the U.S in 2008. However, in 2019, Representative Ocasio-Cortez and Senator Markey championed the policy and successfully advocated for its passing, which could be credited to the efforts of the civil societies firmly demanding an economic paradigm shift (Conte, 2019). In other jurisdictions such as Europe, the GND concept has gained similar popularity, especially with the proposal for the EU region to embrace and adopt a circular economy model, incorporating the aspects of a GND (European Commission 2019).
The popularity of GNDs is due to the promise of addressing sustainability agendas and focusing on social and economic justice, side-lined in linear economic and climate action discourses. With a solid cross-cutting approach, GNDs are structured to favour rapid transition frameworks, including the popular area of energy, focusing on the phasing out of fossil fuels to lower emissions. The U.S. GND version, for instance, proposes the need to make fossil fuels unattractive by rising fuel prices, akin to approaches like carbon taxation and carbon offsets (Fischer and Jacobsen, 2021). While the latter is subject to contemporary debates about its moral purpose in business milieus, it will play a key role in bringing financial capacities to southern geographies, should the concept be extended to other economies. GNDs can further be crafted to encourage governments to undertake Research and Development (R & R&D) in green technologies to supply the upcoming market demand in many sectors, such as renewable energies, housing, and others. Interestingly, in the European GND, the target transcends national boundaries and instead cements a regional aim of achieving net-zero emissions by 2050 (European Commission 2019). This is to be completed by ensuring that economic growth is decoupled from resource use and by addressing socioeconomic issues via extensive jobs creation and increased supply of basic amenities like food and clean water and quality healthcare, to name a few. This perspective is interesting, as it highlights possibilities for country-specific GND policies aligning with regional net-zero objectives while ensuring healthy and sustainable cross-border transactions, being key to ensure that geopolitical balances are maintained.
While varying versions of GNDs are geared to become successful shortly, thus, boosting climate actions in different regions, a few areas would still need to be furnished to increase their global acceptability. First, country and region-specific GND policies would need to be emphasized to ensure that most local challenges’ solutions emanate from communities themselves rather than from being proposed by governments. This would provide room for the bottom-up approaches being championed within economic recovery programs in different geographies. By so doing, this will have positive bearings on how limited financial resources are to be utilized; by specifically pressing programs that would have both short-term and long-term impacts on the livelihoods of local communities and how fiscal mechanisms could be used in an equitable way to revitalize local economic landscapes. Without considering this, GNDs may face the threat of being categorized as neo-capitalist philosophical discourse aimed at dictating policy on financially constrained economies. It would further be a strategy to extend the existing inequality gap between different geographical locations and regions. However, suppose the GNDs are to be crafted to embrace an inclusive approach, supporting the formulation, and structuring of country-specific GNDs. In that case, it will be possible to align shareholder and stakeholder interest and further attract the private sector. This way, it will be possible to secure larger financial capacities to support R&D programs required for the development of green technologies and to invest in climate mitigation programs via Public-Private Partnership (PPP) ventures.
Addressing equitable Public-Private financial needs is essential as sustainability transitioning is an expensive undertaking and a potentially disruptive one (Táíwò, 2019; Chatzky and Siripurapu, 2021). Carefully crafted GNDs can thus be positioned as a powerful solution at the national level while promoting economic justice through social frameworks and meeting national, regional, and global targets. This would, however, demand political support across the board. The popularity of the American version reflects this, as even though the proposal could be argued to address both economic and social justice, it received sharp criticisms from republicans (Bloomfield and Steward, 2020), outlining that sustainability transitions may suffer from political polarisation. It would thus be essential to approach sustainability as a cross-cutting theme, beyond politics, and from a multi-scaled lens.