Unemployment metrics understate and only count recent unemployment
Wray et al., Bard College researcher, ‘18
[L.Randall Wray, Levy Economics Institute, Bard College, Flavia Dantas, SUNY-Cortland, Scott Fullwiler, UMKC, Pavlina R. Tcherneva, Levy Economics Institute, Bard College, and Stephanie A. Kelton, Stony Brook University, PUBLIC SERVICE EMPLOYMENT: A PATH TO FULL EMPLOYMENT, Levy Economics Institute, Bard College, 4—18, p. 9-10]
Note: PSE = Public Service Employment (form of job guarantee)
While all these developments are welcome, a closer look at labor markets leaves us less comfortable. Part of the problem is that the official measure of unemployment does not count many of those without work who do want jobs and those with part-time work who want to work full time. After reaching its lowest postcrisis levels in October and November 2017, the broader U-6 unemployment rate7 remained at 8.2 percent in January and February of 2018. In February 2018, there were 6.7 million people unemployed, 5.3 million people employed part time for economic reasons, and 1.6 million people marginally attached to the labor force. A large portion of the marginally attached were discouraged over job prospects (could not find a job) or out of the labor force for other factors that made participation difficult, including childcare and other family responsibilities or lack of access to the means of transportation to work. This is not surprising, given the difficulty of accessing affordable, available, and adequate childcare and public transportation in the United States.
However, even the U-6 measure of unemployment is likely to understate the challenges, because the Bureau of Labor Statistics considers the “marginally attached” to include only those officially out of the labor force who want a job, are available now, and have searched for employment in the previous year. In February 2018, there were an additional 3 million people outside of the labor force who wanted a job then but had not searched for work in the previous year. Taking these people into account, a more comprehensive measure boosts the rate of idle labor to 10.2 percent, a measure labelled “Augmented Labor Underutilization Rate” in Figure 1.1. This means there were approximately 17 million people who would have wanted a job in the United States in February 2018.