Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Tying economic incentives to climate policies increases public support and coalition-building.

Bergquist et al., 2020 (Parrish Bergquist, Assistant Professor at the McCourt School of Public Policy at Georgetown; Matto Mildenberger, Assistant Professor of Political Science at UC Santa Barbara, and Leah C Stokes, Anton Vonk Associate Professor of Environmental Politics in the Department of Political Science at UCSB, 5-12-2020, “Combining climate, economic, and social policy builds public support for climate action in the US,” Environmental Research Letters, Volume 15 (5), https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/ab81c1, GDI-MAM)

Overall, our results emphasize that including social and economic programs expands support for climate policies. While we do find heterogeneity in support—particularly as a function of partisanship–the net effect is positive. We also find that climate policy support is strongest among African Americans when social policies are included, but that Hispanic and non-Hispanic Whites are also broadly supportive of these programs. While the presence of a carbon tax increases Democratic support for policy packages, the way that tax revenues are used does not have a marginal impact on overall support. While some have argued that a revenue-neutral carbon tax might garner more support among Republicans than other carbon tax designs, we do not find evidence for this claim.

While our results provide empirical support for climate policy bundling, they also highlight some potential political pitfalls. For instance, reformers in some jurisdictions have embraced electric vehicle mandates which may reduce public support. Some social commitments (government-run health insurance and free college tuition) are polarizing, while others (affordable housing and a $15 minimum wage) are neutral or even unifying. Technological investments (e.g. direct air capture) are popular, despite apparent resistance to certain forms of technological investments by leading advocates (McGrath 2019). Political optimization is, of course, a separate issue from whether current proposals will effectively mitigate climate risks. The experiment also highlights the stiff penalty that cost imposes on support for a climate policy bundle. The cost (in support) of cost (in dollars) is substantial for the overall package. Still, the overall and group-level AMCE's suggest the policy elements that policy makers should emphasize to build enough support to overcome the loss of support associated with rising costs.

Of course, while anticipatory attitudes are important to consider, policy debate, enactment, and implementation can influence public opinion. While the public may not express strong ex ante preferences for how climate policies are constructed, policies might distribute costs and benefits in ways that reinforce (Campbell 2012) or undermine (Stokes 2020) public support. Still, our results provide reasons for optimism about a new climate advocacy tactic. Bundling climate, social, and economic policies has the potential to expand the pool of citizens who support climate reforms and unlock public coalitions in support of ambitious climate policymaking.

This evaluation of an influential new climate policymaking strategy offers an important empirical perspective on current climate politics debates, including in the context of stimulus debates associated with the COVID-19 health and economic crisis. Backlash to carbon pricing schemes in France, Australia, and Canada reflect increasingly salient concerns about the inequitable incidence of climate policy costs. Bundling initiatives reflect efforts to address these concerns directly. We build on work suggesting that bundling different types of policy interventions can expand support for policies to reduce emissions in the transportation sector (Wicki et al 2019a, Wicki et al 2019b). But omnibus proposals like the Green New Deal are distinct from these narrower sector-specific proposals. We offer the first empirical test of the implications of bundling a sweeping, economy-wide carbon tax with broad-ranging social and economic programs. This contribution is substantial, since the bundling strategy has generated heated debate in the United States, a country that has repeatedly been an obstacle to global climate cooperation. Any effective global climate crisis response will require the emergence of a pro-climate reform coalition in the United States. Moreover, these results are relevant beyond the US federal context; they may speak to climate policy debates in other parts of the world and in American cities and states. In April 2019, Spain's government won re-election on an ambitious platform that combined social, economic, and climate reforms, and cities and states in the US are considering similar comprehensive approaches. Moreover, governments around the world are increasingly debating stimulus measures to respond to the COVID-19 crisis. They are evaluating whether these economic recovery packages should also push energy, transportation, and industrial systems towards a lower carbon future. To further develop our understanding of the political viability of the bundling strategy, future research should assess public support for bundling climate, social, and economic policy around the world; at the subnational level in the US; and in contexts like the COVID-19 crisis where economic recovery packages provide an opportunity to decarbonize society.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.