Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Turn - Job guarantee automatically stabilizes the economy through recessions and empowers the private sector during growth periods

Barrantes-Fernández et al. 2023 (Telma Barrantes-Fernández , Esteban Cruz-Hidalgo, José Francisco Rangel-Preciado, and Francisco Manuel Parejo-Moruno, Decommodify the 2030 Agenda: Why and How to Finance What Is Not Profitable?, Sustainability 2023, 15, 3966. https://doi.org/10.3390/su15053966)

The job guarantee is, in general terms, an automatic stabilizer that works by employing workers who cannot find a job in the private sector. During economic recessions, the program will expand in size, whereas during economic booms its size will decrease due to increased demand for private sector employment [100,101]. Participation in the program is voluntary. The state sets the wage it pays for activating the workforce, and individuals choose whether to participate. In other words, the total expenditure for this mechanism is not determined by the state, unlike other programs regardless of their objectives. Mitchell and Muysken [102] (pp. 141–142) point out that the size and direction of the public budget is an endogenous result. This can be understood through a basic understanding of how automatic stabilizers work: a sharp drop in demand reduces tax revenue and increases spending on, for example, unemployment benefits, automatically increasing the public deficit. Attempting to limit the effect of automatic stabilizers or even suppress them to conform to a budgetary balance rule only deepens the recession. This is because households and companies rely on others’ spending, and if the state is forced to cut spending, the monetary gains that it generates by maintaining purchasing power to soften the fall in demand will disappear, resulting in more job losses and company failures. The aim is that these programs are mainly temporary and do not require specialized training. They can be designed in a flexible manner to include groups that are frequently excluded from the labor market: the chronically ill, ex-convicts, disabled workers, young people entering the labor market for the first time, ethnic minorities, or people who have been out of the labor market for a long time for any reason [103]. In regard to the topic at hand, artists also fall under the category of people who are frequently excluded from the labor market, with high unemployment rates, low wages, and chronic insecurity [104–106]. This is due to the nature of artistic activity and its incompatibility with capitalist values, as explained in Section 2 of this article. These jobs do not compete with the need for public employment and the traditional welfare state, but rather should be considered as a beneficial job for society that provides a bridge to the private sector, although this transition may not always be necessary, especially for artists, due to their unique characteristics. According to the labor preference model, the artist values emotional income over monetary income, resulting in a higher level of satisfaction compared to what they would obtain from engaging in another activity [107,108].

In this way, market forces determine the size and direction of the public budget automatically. The job guarantee operates as an anchor for prices and wages, effectively replacing the traditional method of controlling inflation by maintaining a reserve army of the unemployed with a reserve of employees. In times of economic recession, when companies lay off workers, those who become unemployed will have the option to take part in these last resort jobs, which help to balance swings in private spending and investment. During economic growth, private employers will be able to hire workers from the pool, by offering better working conditions. The maintenance and improvement of individual skills and abilities compensates for any increase in wages, preventing an inflationary spiral. Mitchell and Mosler [109] referred to this reserve of employees that maintains stable inflation as the non-accelerating inflation buffer employment ratio (NAIBER), as an alternative to the natural unemployment rate used by mainstream economics to control inflation.

The programs would be funded through coordination between the treasury and the central bank, with the government serving as the “employer of last resort” in a manner similar to the central bank’s role as the “lender of last resort” for maintaining financial stability. Just as private banks introduce credit into the economy to meet the demand for loans to start production processes, the demand for income can also activate unused resources, providing them with useful employment that would certainly offset the high individual and social costs of unemployment [110,111]. This allows market forces to determine the size and direction of the public budget. The job guarantee would act as a nondiscretionary operational rule, but it can also be considered a constitutional rule “under the rule of Leviathan”, to use the words of Brennan and Buchanan [112] (p. 351), enabling active fiscal policy without falling into fiscal dominance [113].

Unemployment, as Tcherneva [114] explains, operates in our communities like an epidemic, and as we have learned from the current COVID-19 pandemic, we respond to pandemics by doing everything necessary to stop them [115]. But unemployment is not the only challenge we face. There are many challenges outlined in the 17 SDGs of the 2030 Agenda. Designing job guarantee programs to meet these objectives and doing so through culture and the arts is a crucial commitment that must be explored for their effective implementation. We know, given the unique characteristics of the labor market for artists and creative professionals [28,34–41,52–55,116,117], that we have the human resources available to accomplish them.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.