Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Job Guarantee results in GDP increases, and the costs of unemployment outweigh.

Tcherneva, Bard Economcis Associate professor, ‘18

[Pavlina R. Tcherneva, Associate Professor, Economics, Bard College and Levy Economics Institute, “The Job Guarantee: Design, Jobs, and Implementation,” WORKING PAPER n. 902, Levy Economics Institute of Bard College, 4—18, p. 34-36]

3. How much will the program cost?

The JG program is a separate program that pays a living wage. It is not tied to other anti-poverty programs and does not require people to work for their benefits. When a person opts to take the JG job, they will no longer receive unemployment insurance (UI) or other anti-poverty assistance, thereby reducing spending on these programs.

As above, a generous JG program that employs between 11–16 million people at $15 per hour plus benefits will result in a net expenditure of 0.8 percent to 2 percent of GDP (Fullwiler forthcoming). These estimates include expected reductions in spending on other programs such as UI, Medicaid, and earned income tax credits (EITC).

However, these estimates are based on very conservative assumptions regarding potential savings on a wide range of other federal, state, and local programs that are targeted to lowincome households. In 2015, for example, the federal government spent $104 billion on food and nutritional service programs, including $74 billion for the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), $21 billion for Child Nutrition, $6 billion for the Women, Infants, and Children program (WIC), $17.3 billion on Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (TANF), $50 billion in housing assistance, and $64 billion on EITC, to name some of the main anti-poverty expenditures. Additionally, total direct spending by states for social services and income maintenance for those on public welfare was $505 billion (this does not include spending on health, policing, or corrections).

Research indicates that most social problems—from homelessness and child malnourishment, to mental and physical health problems, to certain types of crime—are connected in one way or another to unemployment. For example, the average cost of incarceration in the United States is $35,000 per year per inmate, which is slightly below the $37,440 in wages and benefits that the JG provides. In New York State, the cost is $75,000 per inmate—the equivalent of two JG jobs. And in New York City, it is $169,000 per inmate per year, or equal to four-and-a-half livingwage JG jobs.

Many of those who are behind bars for economic reasons (i.e., related to the absence of stable well-paid jobs and the associated pathologies unemployment creates) would be better served by taking up a JG job instead. Thus the federal JG program will also be a boon to state finances, causing large-scale savings on incarceration and other anti-poverty measures.

All of these savings are not estimated in the cost calculations above. A more elaborate model will be needed to estimate the reduction in medical expenditures, incarceration costs, and other anti-poverty measures, as well as the positive social multipliers and growth that would result from implementing a JG.

It is conceivable that if we included all social and economic benefits—including reductions in poverty, indebtedness, crime and incarceration, and improvements to physical and mental health—the impact on the federal government budget would be far less (and the positive impact on state budgets would be larger) than what we are reporting in Dantas, Fullwiler, Kelton, Tcherneva, and Wray (forthcoming).

Finally, it is important to note that the real costs of unemployment (in terms of wasted human and physical resources, forgone output, poverty, and other social ills) are the real burden on our communities and future generations—a burden that we already carry. We are already “paying” for unemployment. In financial and real terms, the costs of unemployment today outweigh the financial and real costs of running a JG.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.