Critiques ignore private sector is already cyclical – aff provides more stability
Tcherneva, Bard Economics Associate professor, ‘20
[Pavlina R. Tcherneva, Associate Professor, Economics, Bard College, THE CASE FOR A JOB GUARANTEE, Polity Press, Medford MA, 2020, epub]
Critics also worry that the Job Guarantee cannot function as an effective automatic stabilizer. Can we really create jobs on demand? If they are so useful, why let Job Guarantee workers go when the economy recovers?
This criticism fails to recognize that the private sector behaves cyclically already. The ability to absorb or shed employees is not a unique challenge for the Job Guarantee. Indeed every labor market segment within the private, non-profit, or public sectors deals with new entrants and job leavers on an ongoing basis. It is in the nature of the structural and cyclical changes of the economy. But because the Job Guarantee is a better stabilizer than unemployment, it would significantly reduce the current yo-yo effect in labor markets. Smaller fluctuations in private employment mean smaller fluctuations in the Job Guarantee and easier transitions, removing the challenge of accommodating large swaths of people on short notice. Additionally, once the program has been established, many of the specific projects described above could be scaled up or down relatively quickly, as workers enter or leave the Job Guarantee.
Essential and ongoing public services need to be staffed on a permanent basis. The Environmental Protection Agency and the Food and Drug Administration are in need of many more inspectors, but these are not temporary Job Guarantee jobs. Similarly, with respect to the professionalized childcare benefit of the program, it should be noted that this too would be a mainline government function, although these childcare centers could hire temporary trainees and teacher assistants through the program. Professionalized affordable childcare is permanent infrastructure. It is a public option for childcare. Whether working parents have jobs in the Job Guarantee program or elsewhere, they would still need childcare.