Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

‘Disrupting’ an exploitative economy creates protections for workers regardless of business complaints.

Tcherneva, Bard Economics Associate professor, ‘20

[Pavlina R. Tcherneva, Associate Professor, Economics, Bard College, THE CASE FOR A JOB GUARANTEE, Polity Press, Medford MA, 2020, epub]

On the Program’s “Disruptive” Effects

In the IT world, disruptions are hailed as progressive and innovative. One innovation of the Job Guarantee program is that it compels firms to match its living-wage floor (though this goal would be reached faster if the federal minimum wage were also increased as the program was being implemented). For some critics, this is dangerous because workers outside the program would realize that they do not enjoy the decent pay, healthcare, and childcare of Job Guarantee workers and might stage a “political rebellion.”12 This critique is a thinly veiled argument in support of the firms’ privilege to pay poverty wages.

A similar critique plagued the New Deal’s Civil Works Administration. As Philip Harvey notes, the problem with the CWA was not that it was unpopular but that it was widely popular.13 Firms (not their workers) protested that the program offered too much job security, and southern racist employers argued that the higher public wages were “ruining” black workers, giving them the “wrong incentives.” Farmers complained that they were losing cheap farm workers to the more stable civil public works, even though the CWA wages were well below the national average. The political attack came under the usual pretext that the program was busting the federal budget and that it was time to cancel it and replace it with the dole. Had Roosevelt reauthorized the program, it may have been impossible to ever end it. This was the verdict of FDR’s conservative budget director, Lewis Douglas, who was no friend of the CWA.14 Workers liked the program and started to regard the projects it offered as their right, as something the government owed them.

It is true that one major goal of the Job Guarantee is to disrupt those businesses that can only be successful by paying poverty wages. Euthanizing poverty paying jobs through the Job Guarantee is a feature, not a bug of the program, and the complaints will come from firms not their workers. Even in the midst of the Great Depression, firms wanted to keep the threat of the sack, and much preferred a welfare system that subsidized their access to cheap labor. But there is no reason to believe that the Job Guarantee will be violently disruptive to the private sector. As discussed above, our model indicates that it significantly increases real GDP and private sector employment. In reality, although firms protest all increases in the minimum wage, they have no trouble matching them, and the economic benefits of raising wages are well documented.15

Critics also want us to fear the impact the Job Guarantee will have on public employment. The worry is that the program’s living-wage floor would induce both the private and public sectors to engage in race-to-the bottom wage cutting to match the guaranteed floor. This critique implies that instituting a public option – any public option – degrades the existing benefits of people who may not need to access it. It is like saying that Social Security should not have been implemented because it would have reduced both government and private pensions. But in the US, even federal employees who have Social Security enjoy supplemental federal public retirement plans. Public options do not create a race to the bottom; they raise and secure the floor.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.