“Make work” is a false choice that centers projects over workers.
Tcherneva, Bard Economics Associate professor, ‘20
[Pavlina R. Tcherneva, Associate Professor, Economics, Bard College, THE CASE FOR A JOB GUARANTEE, Polity Press, Medford MA, 2020, epub]
On Make-Work and False Choices
The fear that Job Guarantee projects would necessarily be make-work amounts to what James Galbraith called “an admission of impotence and a call for preemptive surrender.”11 Indeed, New Deal projects were often derided as boondoggles, yet they rebuilt communities, the economy, and people’s lives.
The “make-work” canard, however, is not entirely ideological. A charitable interpretation is that it stems from a confusion over purpose. Is the Job Guarantee a program that provides jobs to everyone who needs one, or is it a program that creates “productive” projects? If it is a policy for useful work, the argument goes, it cannot possibly employ everyone. If it is a policy for the unemployed, then it cannot possibly be productive.
These of course are false choices. The program is productive because it eliminates the negative return from joblessness, and because it stabilizes the economy better than unemployment. However, jobs programs that fail to reaffirm the access to a basic job as a human right will inevitably fail to answer the questions that troubled the New Deal projects: Who should be employed? Are they skilled enough? Are the projects useful? Shouldn’t they be staffed with more skilled workers? When the emphasis is on the project, rather than on the person, it invariably becomes difficult to advocate for jobs for all. That becomes possible when the emphasis is on the scourge of unemployment and the need to guarantee the basic economic right to a job.