Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Aff solves for the service sector – living-wage incentive reigns in private sector,

Tcherneva, Bard Economics Associate professor, ‘20

[Pavlina R. Tcherneva, Associate Professor, Economics, Bard College, THE CASE FOR A JOB GUARANTEE, Polity Press, Medford MA, 2020, epub]

This new labor standard would be especially beneficial to service sector workers. The vast majority of workers who would transition to private sector employment from the Job Guarantee would take up service sector jobs, as manufacturing today employs less than 8 percent of the total labor force in the US. The decline in manufacturing employment is a global trend, and even manufacturing giants like China and South Korea cannot count on this sector to maintain previous levels of employment. We often think with nostalgia about manufacturing jobs, longing for the family security they provided and the communities they engendered. But it is easy to forget that manufacturing jobs were precarious and underpaid until organized labor unionized them and governments legislated for workplace safety, working hour limits, and minimum wages. Those changes were far-reaching but still inadequate. They depended on the mutual expectations and obligations between workers and employers over labor conditions. The social contract, which ushered in family wages for men (but only “pin money” for women), is now long gone, and service sector work does not provide comparable wage support and living standards.

Yet the overwhelming majority of jobs in the economy are what we could broadly call care work; that is, service sector employment that deals with nurturing and reproducing society. We transport ourselves, feed and clothe ourselves, entertain ourselves, and educate and heal ourselves. But many of these jobs are undervalued and underpaid. How can we do for service jobs what we once did for manufacturing jobs? Minimum wage and work safety laws are not enough.

The Job Guarantee offers a different contract with the American public. Multinational corporations today have no incentive to do what Ford once did – raise worker pay to boost purchasing power and demand for the products the corporation makes. As a structural policy, the living-wage public option for jobs provides the incentive. It puts corporations’ feet to the fire and requires that, if they wish to do business in a country that has implemented a Job Guarantee, they must at least match the program’s pay.

One may wonder whether corporations would respond by simply outsourcing more jobs to low-wage countries. However, the service sector employs nearly 80 percent of all workers in the US and most service sector jobs cannot be outsourced easily. Call centers and some accounting services maybe, but schools, grocery stores, restaurants, transportation, home repair services, health clinics, dialysis centers, retirement homes, golf courses, and theaters cannot be shipped abroad. Nor are they being radically automated. The primary threat hanging over workers in this sector is not outsourcing or automation, but downsizing, pay cuts, harassment, benefit loss, or other difficult working conditions employers create in the race to cut costs. A worker has no power to say “no” to a bad job unless they are guaranteed the option of a good job with decent pay.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.