JG bridges the ideological gap.
Tcherneva, Bard Economics Associate professor, ‘20
[Pavlina R. Tcherneva, Associate Professor, Economics, Bard College, THE CASE FOR A JOB GUARANTEE, Polity Press, Medford MA, 2020, epub]
When the Job Guarantee reentered the political discourse in the US in 2018, a number of surveys tried to gauge its popularity. A Hill-HarrisX poll from October 2019 found that a whopping 78 percent of voters supported the Job Guarantee,1 including 71 percent of Republicans, 87 percent of Democrats, 81 percent of Independents, 78 percent of leaning Conservative, and 52 percent of strongly Conservative voters. Few policies have such overwhelming bipartisan support.
One polling firm (Civis Analytics), which used a deliberately partisan framing, still found that a majority of voters (52 percent) supported the program, including 58 percent of Obama-to-Trump voters, and 32 percent of Trump voters, calling it “one of the most popular issues we’ve ever polled.”2 Looking at the state level (Figure 5), another polling firm (Data for Progress) found strong support in deep Republican states as well: Mississippi (72 percent), Georgia (71 percent), Kansas (67 percent), West Virginia (62 percent), and Indiana (61 percent). Each of these states has higher-than-average unemployment and poverty rates where the Job Guarantee could have a big impact.
Once paired with the Green New Deal (GND) agenda, Data for Progress finds that overall program support increases to 55 percent.3 When it is framed as green, it also becomes more popular among Trump voters by 14 percent than a Job Guarantee without the green framing.
But the public has always supported job creation and specifically programs where the government acts as an employer of last resort. A 2013 Gallup Poll reported that between 72 and 77 percent of respondents supported government employment programs and job creation laws that would employ the unemployed.4
Another study found that 68 percent of the general public believed that the government should “see to it that everyone who wants work should find a job,” and 53 percent supported the idea of the government itself providing jobs to the unemployed as a last resort (Table 3).5
The longstanding Kinder Houston Area Study by the Kinder Institute for Urban Research has been polling since 1989 whether “the government should see to it that everyone who wants to work can find a job,” finding consistently that over 64 percent of respondents supported the idea.6 After the Great Financial Crisis, that number edged up to 69 percent in 2009, and by 2016, 76 percent of people believed that it was the government’s responsibility to ensure that everyone who wanted a job had one. Like other polls, the Kinder survey shows that government employment policies are more popular than other income redistribution and poverty-reducing measures (Figure 6).
In sum, with or without a green framing, a majority of Americans support not only government employment programs, but also employer of last resort and Job Guarantee programs in particular.