Mass inequality locks in secular stagnation
Banerjee and Bivens ‘22
(Asha Banerjee and Josh Bivens. Asha was a policy analyst at the Center for Law and Social Policy and is now an economic analyst at the EPI; Master of Philosophy (MPhil), Economic and Social History, University of Oxford. Josh has a Ph.D., Economics, economic author, and director of research at EPI. Economic Policy Institute. Will secular stagnation return? The stakes for current economic debates and fiscal policy. . August 4, 2022. Accessed 01/06/2023. AR)
Drawing on a recent paper by Banerjee and Bivens (2022), this policy memo makes the following points:
Secular stagnation is real. The existence of a chronic shortfall in aggregate demand relative to the economy’s productive capacity—often short-handed as “secular stagnation”—prior to the COVID-19 pandemic has been extremely well-documented. Inequality and other causes of secular stagnation have not disappeared. Secular stagnation in the U.S. economy very likely was not driven by a one-off policy mistake or economic influence. Almost every plausible candidate for its appearance has deep structural roots that will likely persist well past the economic shock of the pandemic. One of the most important likely drivers of secular stagnation is the very large upward redistribution of income occurring over decades. As Banerjee and Bivens (2022) found, from 1979 to 2007, 10% of total national income moved from less affluent households (who spend a higher share of their incomes) to more affluent households, those in the top 1% (who spend a lower share, and who already were securing a disproportionate share of national income. The effects of the Great Recession and financial crisis moved this figure down a bit, but even as of 2018 the share of income held by the top 1% was nearly 8% higher than in 1979. As Banerjee and Bivens (2022) show, shifting greater shares of income to affluent households (whose savings rates far eclipse lower-income households’ savings rates) drags on household spending growth. The structural forces behind secular stagnation would likely serve as a future break on inflation. Given the high likelihood that the structural drivers of secular stagnation persist throughout the pandemic business cycle, any inflationary pressure driven by excess demand growth should face stiff headwinds before too long, and thus should be easier to tame than during previous periods of demand-driven inflation. The structural forces behind secular stagnation would likely fortify a recession springing from excessive anti-inflation measures. At the same time, given the likelihood that the structural drivers of secular stagnation persist throughout the pandemic business cycle, any recession caused by a too-aggressive stance in fighting inflation (say, by the Fed raising interest rates too fast and too high) will be quite stubborn and will require aggressive expansionary policy to rapidly recover from (Bivens 2022b).