Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

UBI funded by progressive income tax topically redistributes

Jason Leman ’18, September 27, “WHY SHOULD A UBI PILOT BE TAXING?” https://www.ubilabnetwork.org/blog/should-a-ubi-pilot-be-taxing

So we need to have a good idea of how we will fund a UBI and whether it is additional to, or a development of, the current welfare state. To underline how the detail matters, let’s consider the third scenario, where a progressive income tax funds a UBI. This is the model on the right of Figures 1 and 2. This scheme costs around half that of the scheme where the tax and benefits system were left untouched. We adjust the UBI given to people in the pilot according to what benefits they receive and the additional taxes they would pay under a more progressive income tax. In fact, at some income level people will become net losers, as they are required to pay more tax under the proposed UBI scheme than they do currently. Quite where the tipping point would be depends on the detail: what level of taxation is required, whether the UBI would be maintained if tax revenue fell, and whether it would only be funded through income tax. There are wider issues that it would be hard to model and where there is conflicting evidence, such as likely tax avoidance and resistance to increasing income tax. A pilot would not be able to answer all these questions, not least because most people would not voluntarily pay more taxes under a pilot scheme. However, transparency about funding would allow for a conversation to be had as part of a pilot.

I favour Universal Basic Income as a means of redistributing income, profits and wealth. I would argue that a mix of funding would be best, to help rebalance the economy alongside rebalancing individual income. This may involve closing tax loopholes, raising taxes on profits or transactions, alongside a more progressive income tax model. The UK currently has a regressive tax system because of the high levels of indirect taxes that hit the poor. Yet, changing the tax system isn’t a simple option. Many tax reliefs have the intention of creating socially beneficial outcomes. Increasing indirect taxes or corporation tax significantly would impact on producers and consumers in multiple ways. Any pilot needs to include at least an outline modelling of the impact of these tax changes and have a coherent argument driving them.

Redistribution aims to smooth out the huge inequalities between people. These inequalities have far more to do with luck and position than fabled hard-work and inventiveness. It’s hard to get rich without trying, but it’s equally difficult to get out of poverty just through hard work. Our country gives us the freedom to be wealth blessed or poverty ridden, with an individual responsibility that would be welcome if it were not so wilfully ignorant of structural obstacles and cultural privileges. The UK, and England in particular, has a tradition of individual freedom that makes income redistribution a difficult topic to broach. This political challenge makes many shy away from redrawing the tax and benefit system. Yet, for the reasons set out above, a pilot cannot avoid making clear decisions.

We can present UBI as a way of valuing individuals, or developing the welfare state, or rebalancing the economy, or all three. A Universal Basic Income could buffer us from the Russian Roulette of a free market whilst removing the whip-hand of conditionality. Whatever moral basis we decide upon [2], that needs to drive decisions on funding, all of which needs to be defined and communicated in a pilot. A pilot is critical for informing us about what impact a real UBI will have, but it’s also essential for stimulating discussion about where the money comes from and why. Implementing a full UBI doesn’t just need an evidential base, but also a solid base of popular support for change. That’s why we need to start the discussion now.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.