Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Their defense assumes abstract proposals – plan hits the sweet spot

MICHAEL HILTZIK, BUSINESS COLUMNIST, ’17. JUNE 23, 2017, “Column: Conservatives, liberals, techies, and social activists all love universal basic income: Has its time come?” LOS ANGELES TIMES, https://www.latimes.com/business/hiltzik/la-fi-hiltzik-ubi-20170625-story.html

The main challenge for UBI advocates is defining just what such a program would look like on a large scale. “UBI proposals tend not to be fully baked,” observed liberal economist Max Sawicky. That was in 2013. Some four years later, it’s still true. Some projects are operating under the radar, including the Oakland project, on which Y Combinator’s Altman declined to comment.

Indeed, one reason UBI attracts adherents across the ideological spectrum is that it can be so variously conceived. It’s a bit like the story of the blind men and the elephant, with every promoter visualizing the totality based on the features he or she considers most important.

Conservatives like UBI because they think it can replace the web of social assistance programs we have now, presumably at a lower cost. Political scientist Charles Murray, for example, has asserted that a guaranteed income of $10,000 a year would be enough to eliminate “Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, welfare programs, social service programs, agricultural subsidies, and corporate welfare,” while leaving in place public funding of education, the transportation infrastructure, the courts and a few other services.

Progressives tend to think in terms of using UBI to modernize the social safety net to accommodate the modern workplace, including “the growth of contingent work” such as driving for Uber or Lyft, says Foster. A universal guaranteed income “gives people the flexibility to deal with changes in the labor market.”

Of course, people on both sides also find plenty not to like. Sawicky expressed a common liberal concern that the universal basic income movement was a pipe dream that would distract from more achievable efforts to improve, not replace, existing programs. Conservatives blanch at the “moral hazard” of just handing out money, regardless of need.

To the extent there’s a consensus in the U.S., it’s that a guaranteed income program should provide at least $12,000 a year. The ideal program would be truly universal to remove the stigma attached to means-tested programs such as food stamps. Nor would the payments phase out with rising income to eliminate what conservatives decry as the “poverty trap” — when more income means the loss of benefits, they posit, recipients are encouraged to stay out of the labor pool.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.