Risk homeostasis is a debunked theory
Barry Pless ’16. “Risk Compensation: Revisited and Rebutted,” MDPI, Safety 2016, 2(3), 16; https://doi.org/10.3390/safety2030016https://www.mdpi.com/2313-576X/2/3/16
An early topic chosen to support the RC theory was traffic accidents in general and seat belt use in particular. It was argued that any traffic safety measure was entirely offset by increased speeding or more careless driving (as Peltzman asserted it would). However, as Evans writes, “to examine the validity of this claim, using a wide variety of traffic accident data, all the data examined are found to be incompatible with the risk homeostasis theory… The accident data provide evidence that a rich variety of user responses occur. While it is possible for users to collectively respond in such a way that safety benefits are completely cancelled, such a response is not particularly common; it is certainly not universally occurring, as suggested by the risk homeostasis theory. It is concluded that the risk homeostasis theory should be rejected because there is no convincing evidence supporting it and much evidence refuting it.” [10].