Welfare trade-off hurts the same people UBI wants to protect
Alyssa Battistoni, PhD candidate in political science at Yale University and an editor at Jacobin magazine, 17, Spring 2017, “The False Promise of Universal Basic Income,” DISSENT https://www.dissentmagazine.org/article/false-promise-universal-basic-income-andy-stern-ruger-bregman/
But you don’t need to be Robespierre to be suspicious of a proposal that explicitly announces its intent to protect the rich from working-class rage—particularly when one of the major questions of UBI is where the free money will come from. Stern cautions UBI supporters against advocating a “soak the rich” tax on political grounds: the broad coalition that UBI requires will be impossible if the rich are against it from the start. (Alas, this is already the metric for most policies.) Instead, he proposes to fund UBI by cashing out major welfare programs (food stamps, housing assistance, the earned income tax credit) and charging a value-added tax on consumer goods; more tentatively, he considers a wealth tax, a financial transaction tax, and cuts to military spending. But funding a basic income by cannibalizing existing welfare programs and imposing regressive consumption taxes perversely places the burden of subsidizing low wages on the poor and working-class people making them in the first place.